Alan Milburn has warned that immediate cuts to young people’s benefits would deepen poverty and increase crime-related costs, defending a youth employment plan whose projected net saving reaches £200m a year after a decade.

The former Labour health secretary argues that reducing welfare without creating opportunities merely shifts expenditure elsewhere. Young people left destitute, he said, would generate greater housing, health and crime costs. “The answer on benefits in my view is not crude cuts, it’s more jobs.”

Almost one million people aged 16 to 24 are neither in education, employment nor training; six in 10 have never held a job. His government-commissioned review warns that the total could reach 1.27 million by 2031 without reform.

Milburn proposes a youth opportunity service throughout England by 2029, with legal guarantees of a route into employment or training and the support to pursue it. Hiring subsidies, more apprenticeships and faster mental health support would accompany a new youth allowance replacing existing under-25 benefits, the abolition of extra sickness payments and more tailored disability support.

He argues that many young people with anxiety, depression, ADHD or autism could work with suitable help, while explicitly acknowledging that not everyone can. Some Labour MPs are reported to have raised concerns about proposals to end young people’s eligibility for personal independence payments or Universal Credit’s health element.

The financial case rests on £5.8bn in annual spending by 2036, offset by £3.6bn in welfare savings and another £2.4bn from tax revenues and reduced benefit payments as employment rises. The £200m net saving is therefore a forecast dependent on the reforms working, not an immediate budget reduction. Milburn says savings could begin during this parliament and grow beyond the mid-2030s.

Conservative shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately supports his diagnosis but calls the savings speculative and distant. She argues that lower business taxes and less red tape would encourage recruitment more effectively than job subsidies. The Conservatives propose £36bn in annual working-age benefit savings; Reform UK proposes £50bn. Reform economy spokesman Robert Jenrick argues for ending benefits for those choosing not to work and reducing employment costs.

Andy Burnham has echoed Milburn’s warning that abrupt cuts would leave people in crisis and increase pressure on emergency and criminal justice services. Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden argues that reform must deliver better lives, not merely incomes.

Even successful implementation would leave a gap: the review models 440,000 under-25s entering sustained employment by 2036, short of the wider ambition for 600,000 more young people in work or training.