Shabana Mahmood is to announce a fast-stream programme recruiting 200 potential police leaders a year, including people outside law enforcement, to address standards she will describe as “frankly inadequate”.
The home secretary will unveil the scheme at police chiefs’ and leaders’ annual conference in central London on Wednesday. Applicants from any occupation will be eligible without a degree, with a planned five-to-10-year route towards superintendent. Government sources say it is intended to broaden the pool of future leaders; Mahmood’s advisers argue it brings fresh focus and scale.
The announcement follows June’s Police Leadership Commission report, which found leadership was sometimes “staggeringly” poor. Between 2023 and 2025, inspectors rated two forces inadequate and 13 as requiring improvement for leadership. None was outstanding.
Eight serving or former chief constables were also under misconduct investigation across England and Wales’s 43 forces. Mahmood will cite Devon and Cornwall’s experience of paying for three chief constables, two of whom were suspended at one point. Investigations do not establish misconduct.
In extracts released by her aides, Mahmood attributes inconsistent leadership to an earlier failure to invest in developing future leaders. The proposed recruitment route addresses that longer-term shortage, rather than offering an immediate remedy for failings at the top.
Commission co-chair Nick Herbert, a former Conservative policing minister, welcomed the fast stream as a significant step towards implementing its recommendations. He said effective leadership was fundamental to police performance, cutting crime and public safety, and called for reform throughout the service.
Fellow co-chair David Blunkett, the former Labour home secretary, warned against separating accelerated promotion from a comprehensive overhaul of leadership standards and career progression. “Fast-track must not be seen as an elite mechanism,” he said, but as an opportunity for those with ambition and ability.
The Home Office is considering all 27 commission recommendations, including a national leadership academy and increased training funding. Current leadership training spending is about £4m within a service costing £19bn annually.
A separate restructuring decision remains unresolved. Mahmood will not announce how many regional forces would replace the existing 43. An unpublished review she commissioned from Bernard Hogan-Howe reportedly recommended as few as nine. Her speech will stress that local units would handle everyday crime if the changes proceed.
Police leaders also cite financial strain. Figures link early prisoner releases since March to year-on-year increases of 13% in arrests for bail breaches and 8% in arrests to return people to prison. Police estimate the resulting cost at £500m by next March and fear it could rise: an immediate pressure alongside a leadership programme whose benefits would take years.









Join the conversation