London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Wednesday, Oct 22, 2025

Updated: Court delays port vote

Updated: Court delays port vote

The referendum on the controversial cruise and cargo port development will be delayed at least until next year following a court order Tuesday.
The decision to schedule the poll on 19 Dec., before the completion of an updated environmental impact assessment, was challenged in court by Shirley Roulstone, a leading member of the Cruise Port Referendum Cayman campaign group. Roulstone also raised legal concerns about the fairness of the provisions for the referendum.

Grand Court judge Tim Owen granted leave to apply for judicial review to Roulstone and a trial has been provisionally scheduled for 20 Jan., pending courtroom availability.

Justice Owen ordered that the referendum be delayed at least until the judgment is delivered following that trial.

The National Trust had also brought a legal challenge but agreed Tuesday to join its case with Roulstone’s because of the similarity of its arguments on the environmental points.

Justice Owen said Roulstone’s lawyers had met the threshold to proceed to full trial.

He acknowledged government had advanced “strong arguments” in response but said these were not the “knockout blows” necessary for him to dismiss the case at this stage.

“This case plainly involves issues of great constitutional importance for the Cayman Islands – questions which have never been considered before because this is the first time that Section 70 of the Constitution, which provides for a people-initiated referendum has been triggered,” the judge said.

Roulstone’s lawyers argued four main grounds for judicial review:

That Cabinet had pre-determined the question and date before the port referendum legislation had been passed
That Cabinet failed to consider important matters including having “due regard” to protection of the environment, as required by the Constitution
That the question Cabinet set for the referendum was neither fair nor neutral, as required by law
That the failure to provide any campaign-finance limits, frustrated the intent of the Constitution that a free and fair vote should take place
Justice Owen, appearing by video-link from London, granted leave to proceed on all four grounds.

Helen Mountfield QC, representing Roulstone, said there was a “manifest inequality of arms” between government and those opposing the port in terms of their finances.

She said the constitutional duty for a people-initiated-referendum carried with it an implication that it should be a fair and effective referendum.

Mountfield, also speaking by video-link, said the timing, the nature of the question and the lack of campaign-spending restrictions – similar to those required in a general election – suggested this was not government’s plan.

“All of this leads to an inference that government was not intending to have a referendum and prevail on the merits but intended to railroad its view through irrespective of the factors that would make for a fair referendum,” she said.

Mountfield, of UK law firm Matrix Chambers, submitted a legal opinion on government’s Referendum Law for the port, prior to its debate and passage in the Legislative Assembly.

In response, government dropped the date and question from the bill, in an effort to satisfy a condition of the Constitution that those aspects should be set with reference to the legislation after it is published.

Mountfield suggested Cabinet had then simply “rubber stamped” the same date and question, without reference to the concerns Matrix had raised, including the fairness of the phrasing of the question and the need for campaign finance limits.

The lawyers have taken issue with the use of the words “move forward” and “enhanced cargo port” in the question, suggesting the wording is not neutral.

Government’s lawyer Alan Maclean QC, also speaking via video-link, had earlier suggested that Roulstone’s arguments should be thrown out.

“You can’t aggregate four thin points to make one fat point. They are too anorexic to pass on their own,” he said.

He said Cabinet had not simply “rubber stamped” the original question and date but had reconsidered these aspects after the law was passed and agreed to proceed.

He said government was required to consider the environment in its final decision on whether to proceed with the project. But he said this was not a relevant consideration when determining the date of the referendum. He acknowledged, following questions from the judge, that a $200,000 study to determine the scope of works for a potential update to the Environmental Impact Assessment was under way and could theoretically be published the day after the referendum.

But he maintained that it would be unreasonable to expect the vote to be held off indefinitely and suggested a delay of more than a year could be expected if a full EIA update is determined to be necessary.

Referencing the contentious UK Brexit poll, he said it was not a prerequisite of a legal referendum that “full, final and perfect information” be available.

He added that Cayman’s Constitution required government to move quickly to hold the vote.

“The whole thrust of it is that the referendum should be got on with. It is not something that should be kicked into the long grass pending 18 months of further deliberation,” Maclean said.

Lawyers for the National Trust spoke briefly during the hearing and agreed to join their case with Roulstone’s on the basis that they are advancing similar arguments about the lack of up to date environmental information available. Tom Lowe, QC for the National Trust, said government had done the right thing by consulting and carrying out an EIA in the first place but had then negated this by putting out “completely different and misleading” messaging on the environment in advance of the referendum.

A separate application for a protective costs order shielding Roulstone from excessive legal costs if her case is not successful will be heard by the Chief Justice Anthony Smellie on 23 Dec. The National Trust has indicated it will attempt to continue the action in place of Roulstone if such an order is not granted.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
‘Frightening’ First Night in Prison for Sarkozy: Inmates Riot and Shout ‘Little Nicolas’
White House Announces No Imminent Summit Between Trump and Putin
US and Qatar Warn EU of Trade and Energy Risks from Tough Climate Regulation
Apple Challenges EU Digital Markets Act Crackdown in Landmark Court Battle
Nicolas Sarkozy begins five-year prison term at La Santé in Paris
Japan stocks surge to record as Sanae Takaichi becomes Prime Minister
This Is How the 'Heist of the Century' Was Carried Out at the Louvre in Seven Minutes: France Humiliated as Crown with 2,000 Diamonds Vanishes
China Warns UK of ‘Consequences’ After Delay to London Embassy Approval
France’s Wealthy Shift Billions to Luxembourg and Switzerland Amid Tax and Political Turmoil
"Sniper Position": Observation Post Targeting 'Air Force One' Found Before Trump’s Arrival in Florida
Shouting Match at the White House: 'Trump Cursed, Threw Maps, and Told Zelensky – "Putin Will Destroy You"'
Windows’ Own ‘Siri’ Has Arrived: You Can Now Talk to Your Computer
Thailand and Singapore Investigate Cambodian-Based Prince Group as U.S. and U.K. Sanctions Unfold
‘No Kings’ Protests Inflate Numbers — But History Shows Nations Collapse Without Strong Executive Power
Chinese Tech Giants Halt Stablecoin Launches After Beijing’s Regulatory Intervention
Manhattan Jury Holds BNP Paribas Liable for Enabling Sudanese Government Abuses
Trump Orders Immediate Release of Former Congressman George Santos After Commuting Prison Sentence
S&P Downgrades France’s Credit Rating, Citing Soaring Debt and Political Instability
Ofcom Rules BBC’s Gaza Documentary ‘Materially Misleading’ Over Narrator’s Hamas Ties
Diane Keaton’s Cause of Death Revealed as Pneumonia, Family Confirms
Former Lostprophets Frontman Ian Watkins Stabbed to Death in British Prison
"The Tsunami Is Coming, and It’s Massive": The World’s Richest Man Unveils a New AI Vision
Outsider, Heroine, Trailblazer: Diane Keaton Was Always a Little Strange — and Forever One of a Kind
Dramatic Development in the Death of 'Mango' Founder: Billionaire's Son Suspected of Murder
Two Years of Darkness: The Harrowing Testimonies of Israeli Hostages Emerging From Gaza Captivity
EU Moves to Use Frozen Russian Assets to Buy U.S. Weapons for Ukraine
Europe Emerges as the Biggest Casualty in U.S.-China Rare Earth Rivalry
HSBC Confronts Strategic Crossroads as NAB Seeks Only Retail Arm in Australia Exit
U.S. Chamber Sues Trump Over $100,000 H-1B Visa Fee
Shenzhen Expo Spotlights China’s Quantum Step in Semiconductor Self-Reliance
China Accelerates to the Forefront in Global Nuclear Fusion Race
Yachts, Private Jets, and a Picasso Painting: Exposed as 'One of the Largest Frauds in History'
Australia’s Wedgetail Spies Aid NATO Response as Russian MiGs Breach Estonian Airspace
McGowan Urges Chalmers to Cut Spending Over Tax Hike to Close $20 Billion Budget Gap
Victoria Orders Review of Transgender Prison Placement Amid Safety Concerns for Female Inmates
U.S. Treasury Mobilises New $20 Billion Debt Facility to Stabilise Argentina
French Business Leaders Decry Budget as Macron’s Pro-Enterprise Promise Undermined
Trump Claims Modi Pledged India Would End Russian Oil Imports Amid U.S. Tariff Pressure
Surging AI Startup Valuations Fuel Bubble Concerns Among Top Investors
Australian Punter Archie Wilson Tears Up During Nebraska Press Conference, Sparking Conversation on Male Vulnerability
Australia Confirms U.S. Access to Upgraded Submarine Shipyard Under AUKUS Deal
“Firepower” Promised for Ukraine as NATO Ministers Meet — But U.S. Tomahawks Remain Undecided
Brands Confront New Dilemma as Extremists Adopt Fashion Labels
The Sydney Sweeney and Jeans Storm: “The Outcome Surpassed Our Wildest Dreams”
Erika Kirk Delivers Moving Tribute at White House as Trump Awards Charlie Presidential Medal of Freedom
British Food Influencer ‘Big John’ Detained in Australia After Visa Dispute
ScamBodia: The Chinese Fraud Empire Shielded by Cambodia’s Ruling Elite
French PM Suspends Macron’s Pension Reform Until After 2027 in Bid to Stabilize Government
Orange, Bouygues and Free Make €17 Billion Bid for Drahi’s Altice France Telecom Assets
Dutch Government Seizes Chipmaker After U.S. Presses for Removal of Chinese CEO
×