London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Friday, Aug 22, 2025

Counsel for Hong Kong justice minister argues lawmakers’ immunity not unlimited

Counsel for Hong Kong justice minister argues lawmakers’ immunity not unlimited

The suggestion was made in a Court of Final Appeal hearing on the legality of charges brought against ex-opposition lawmaker ‘Long Hair’ Leung Kwok-hung.

A senior counsel representing Hong Kong’s justice minister in a case before the city’s highest court has suggested that a law conferring immunity on legislators may not protect them from criminal sanctions arising from speeches deemed detrimental to national security or the “one country, two systems” principle.

The Court of Final Appeal on Tuesday heard arguments for and against the prosecution of former opposition lawmaker “Long Hair” Leung Kwok-hung, who was charged with contempt of the Legislative Council for snatching a folder from a government official during a 2016 panel meeting.

The trial of the 65-year-old was put on hold after a magistrate held that the accused, then a Legco member, was immune to the charge under the Legislative Council (Powers and Privileges) Ordinance. A higher court later overturned the ruling, finding legislators were not above the law, but that judgment was also appealed.

Counsel for “Longhair” Leung Kwok-hung (pictured) have argued that he enjoys immunity under the Legislative Council (Powers and Privileges) Ordinance.


Johnny Mok Shiu-luen SC, representing the secretary for justice, said the scope of the freedom of speech and debate enjoyed by Legco members was subject to statutory bounds, including offences set out in the 1985 ordinance. The law was initially designed to shield lawmakers from legal troubles in connection with debates in the legislature.

While Section 4 of the ordinance states that no legal proceedings can be launched against a lawmaker “for words spoken before, or written in a report to” a Legco sitting, Section 17 provides that a person who “creates or joins in any disturbance” shall be penalised.

Mok argued the legislation only granted lawmakers immunity over the content of their speeches in Legco, and it would still be possible for a member to be prosecuted for “abnormal” conduct which caused an interruption, such as speaking at the top of his or her voice or throwing objects.

Judge Roberto Ribeiro, one of five judges sitting in Tuesday’s hearing, questioned whether the charge was applicable if a lawmaker caused a disturbance by infuriating his or her colleagues with inflammatory remarks.

While acknowledging that members’ speeches made inside Legco were within the ordinance’s safeguards, Mok said immunity might not apply to remarks that ran contrary to the “basic values and principles” underlying the Basic Law, the city’s mini-constitution.

Such fundamental values included the one country, two systems governing principle, as well as Article 23 of the Basic Law, which required Hong Kong to enact laws of its own prohibiting certain national security offences, the lawyer contended.

“It is possible that … even a [Legco] member may not be at liberty in saying certain things,” Mok told the bench.

However, he quickly clarified that while the government might pursue that argument in future cases, that was not its position in the present appeal.

Leung’s counsel, David Pannick QC, submitted via a live video link from Britain that the Legco ordinance was designed to “keep the court away” from alleged breaches of in-house rules by members, as such outside intervention could impede or deter the performance of the legislature.

It would not have been the legislative intent, the barrister argued, to allow the court to define and set limits on lawmakers’ privilege. Otherwise, a member could be charged with contempt for causing an uproar by advancing serious allegations, such as dishonesty or corruption, against his or her colleagues.

“Members have to be conscious of the risk that they may be prosecuted. It may be a gesture. It may be some noise or some other conduct,” Pannick said.

The court will issue its judgment at a later date.

Leung, who is currently remanded in custody for alleged breaches of the Beijing-imposed national security law in another case, is believed to be the first Legco member prosecuted under Section 17c of the ordinance. The result of the appeal will have a bearing on at least four similar prosecutions.

Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Ukraine Declares De Facto War on Hungary and Slovakia with Terror Drone Strikes on Their Gas Lifeline
Animated K-pop Musical ‘KPop Demon Hunters’ Becomes Netflix’s Most-Watched Original Animated Film
New York Appeals Court Voids Nearly $500 Million Civil Fraud Penalty Against Trump While Upholding Fraud Liability
Elon Musk tweeted, “Europe is dying”
Far-Right Activist Convicted of Incitement Changes Gender and Demands: "Send Me to a Women’s Prison" | The Storm in Germany
Hungary Criticizes Ukraine: "Violating Our Sovereignty"
Will this be the first country to return to negative interest rates?
Child-free hotels spark controversy
North Korea is where this 95-year-old wants to die. South Korea won’t let him go. Is this our ally or a human rights enemy?
Hong Kong Launches Regulatory Regime and Trials for HKD-Backed Stablecoins
China rehearses September 3 Victory Day parade as imagery points to ‘loyal wingman’ FH-97 family presence
Trump Called Viktor Orbán: "Why Are You Using the Veto"
Horror in the Skies: Plane Engine Exploded, Passengers Sent Farewell Messages
MSNBC Rebrands as MS NOW Amid Comcast’s Cable Spin-Off
AI in Policing: Draft One Helps Speed Up Reports but Raises Legal and Ethical Concerns
Shame in Norway: Crown Princess’s Son Accused of Four Rapes
Apple Begins Simultaneous iPhone 17 Production in India and China
A Robot to Give Birth: The Chinese Announcement That Shakes the World
Finnish MP Dies by Suicide in Parliament Building
Outrage in the Tennis World After Jannik Sinner’s Withdrawal Storm
William and Kate Are Moving House – and the New Neighbors Were Evicted
Class Action Lawsuit Against Volkswagen: Steering Wheel Switches Cause Accidents
Taylor Swift on the Way to the Super Bowl? All the Clues Stirring Up Fans
Dogfights in the Skies: Airbus on Track to Overtake Boeing and Claim Aviation Supremacy
Tim Cook Promises an AI Revolution at Apple: "One of the Most Significant Technologies of Our Generation"
Apple Expands Social Media Presence in China With RedNote Account Ahead of iPhone 17 Launch
Are AI Data Centres the Infrastructure of the Future or the Next Crisis?
Cambridge Dictionary Adds 'Skibidi,' 'Delulu,' and 'Tradwife' Amid Surge of Online Slang
Bill Barr Testifies No Evidence Implicated Trump in Epstein Case; DOJ Set to Release Records
Zelenskyy Returns to White House Flanked by European Allies as Trump Pressures Land-Swap Deal with Putin
The CEO Who Replaced 80% of Employees for the AI Revolution: "I Would Do It Again"
Emails Worth Billions: How Airlines Generate Huge Profits
Character.ai Bets on Future of AI Companionship
China Ramps Up Tax Crackdown on Overseas Investments
Japanese Office Furniture Maker Expands into Bomb Shelter Market
Intel Shares Surge on Possible U.S. Government Investment
Hurricane Erin Threatens U.S. East Coast with Dangerous Surf
EU Blocks Trade Statement Over Digital Rule Dispute
EU Sends Record Aid as Spain Battles Wildfires
JPMorgan Plans New Canary Wharf Tower
Zelenskyy and his allies say they will press Trump on security guarantees
Beijing is moving into gold and other assets, diversifying away from the dollar
Escalating Clashes in Serbia as Anti-Government Protests Spread Nationwide
The Drought in Britain and the Strange Request from the Government to Delete Old Emails
Category 5 Hurricane in the Caribbean: 'Catastrophic Storm' with Winds of 255 km/h
"No, Thanks": The Mathematical Genius Who Turned Down 1.5 Billion Dollars from Zuckerberg
The surprising hero, the ugly incident, and the criticism despite victory: "Liverpool’s defense exposed in full"
Digital Humans Move Beyond Sci-Fi: From Virtual DJs to AI Customer Agents
YouTube will start using AI to guess your age. If it’s wrong, you’ll have to prove it
Jellyfish Swarm Triggers Shutdown at Gravelines Nuclear Power Station in Northern France
×