England have the chance to beat New Zealand in successive matches for the first time in 23 years at Twickenham on Saturday, with three of five rugby pundits backing Steve Borthwick’s side to build on last year’s 33–19 victory.

Wins over Australia and Japan have strengthened England’s confidence. New Zealand arrive after a 35–28 defeat by Wales in Cardiff, their first loss to the Welsh since the 1950s. Yet the forecasts remain close: even those favouring England anticipate a contest that could turn on the replacements.

The three predictions for an England victory are 28–26, 27–19 and 28–20. Their reasoning combines an improving attack, forceful starts in both autumn matches and the physical strength of Borthwick’s bench. One assessment expects the match to remain tight until around the 60-minute mark, when England’s replacements could take control.

Injury has ruled out Immanuel Feyi-Waboso, though one pundit considers Will Joseph a capable understudy. England otherwise retain relatively good availability. By contrast, one assessment puts Dave Rennie’s absences at about six first-choice starters and, arguably, another two players who would make the bench.

Those backing England also question whether New Zealand retain their former psychological advantage. Last year’s result gives Borthwick’s players direct evidence that they can win this fixture, while South Africa have beaten the All Blacks three times in succession this year.

The counterargument rests on who is returning, rather than simply who is missing. New Zealand have recalled Ethan de Groot, Codie Taylor, Fabian Holland and Tupou Vaa’i among the forwards, alongside Cam Roigard, Damian McKenzie, Jordie Barrett and Will Jordan in the backs.

The two forecasts favouring New Zealand are 31–26 and 31–28. Both anticipate a response to the Wales defeat; one also argues that victories over Australia and Japan are an imperfect measure of England’s readiness for this challenge.

The disagreement is therefore more specific than confidence against reputation. England’s supporters expect their recent cohesion and late physical power to prevail. Those favouring New Zealand believe the recalled players can change the balance sufficiently to make the visitors’ last result a poor guide to their next.