Ireland will maintain its European Court of Human Rights case against the UK until the 2023 Troubles Legacy Act is replaced, despite renewed pledges from both governments to work together on securing answers and accountability for victims and their families.
Irish Foreign Affairs Minister Helen McEntee set out that condition after Northern Ireland Secretary Sir Chris Bryant urged Dublin to withdraw the interstate challenge. Their exchange followed Thursday’s British-Irish Intergovernmental Conference at Iveagh House in Dublin, where legacy arrangements were a major focus.
Sir Chris described the governments as “completely and utterly aligned” on legacy and argued that the court case was unnecessary. He said he believed the Legacy Commission would be fully compliant with human rights obligations and that the UK would not undermine any part of the joint framework.
“We all want to make sure that families and victims themselves get the answers that they really, really need,” he said.
Ms McEntee praised the relationship between the governments and confirmed that Ireland intended to withdraw the case. But she distinguished agreement on future arrangements from the legislation currently in force.
“We hope by the spring that will replace the 2023 legislation, but that is still the law, and until that changes, obviously the case will stay as it is.”
Ministers reviewed legislation progressing through Westminster and the Oireachtas to implement the Joint Framework agreed by their predecessors last September. They discussed swift implementation and reciprocal co-operation to build public confidence in legacy arrangements in both jurisdictions. For Dublin, the condition for withdrawing the challenge remains legislative change rather than assurances about what will follow.
A separate disagreement concerned criticism of Irish co-operation by the commission’s head, Sir Declan Morgan. In June, it was contended that the commission had written to the Gardaí eight times seeking information about cases involving 10 murders without receiving replies.
Irish Justice Minister Jim O’Callaghan said he was surprised by Sir Declan’s comments and disagreed with them. Having checked with An Garda Síochána about some of the criticisms, he said he did not believe they had substance.
He also said a statutory body fully compliant with human rights obligations would be in place once the new legislation was enacted. That legislation remains the next concrete step underpinning the governments’ shared commitments.









Join the conversation