Germany, Austria, the Netherlands, Denmark and Greece have announced plans for a return centre in Rwanda, hoping to send 100 adults with no legal right to remain in the EU from early next year.
The five governments said on Monday that concrete negotiations with Rwanda would begin. They are the first to seek to use the EU’s newly agreed returns law, which permits transfers to third countries once people have exhausted appeals against removal.
The pilot would cover adults whose asylum applications have been rejected and others without permission to stay. Unlike the failed British Conservative government scheme or Italy’s arrangement with Albania, it would exclude people still pursuing asylum claims.
The proposed centre would be open, accommodating successive arrivals rather than long-term residents. Diplomatic sources envisage stays of a couple of months before people choose between integrating in Rwanda and returning home. They said British-funded facilities in Kigali would not be used.
The governments argue that the scheme would protect Europe’s asylum system, deter irregular arrivals, undermine smugglers and reduce pressure on their populations. Germany’s interior minister, Alexander Dobrindt, said return hubs offered an option for people whose countries of origin would not cooperate with repatriation. Denmark’s immigration minister, Morten Bødskov, called the announcement “a huge breakthrough”.
That rationale leaves a practical issue: returning home remains one proposed outcome even where a country’s refusal to cooperate has prevented repatriation.
Opponents question both the destination and the safeguards. In 2024, the US state department found that Rwandan security forces and civilian officials committed human rights abuses with impunity, alongside concerns about freedom of expression and forced labour.
Spain’s socialist prime minister, Pedro Sanchez, said: “I don’t see any future or humanity in that. It’s not the solution.” French Green MEP Mélissa Camara called the plan “a grave moral failing”, arguing that people would be deported thousands of kilometres without guarantees that their rights would be respected.
Rights organisations predict failure. Chiara Catelli, of the undocumented migrants’ rights organisation Picum, said transfers would uproot people from lives built in Europe and send them somewhere without family, networks or meaningful prospects.
Andy Burnham said last week that the UK had held no direct discussions with the European governments involved but would watch developments with interest.
Officials expect legal challenges but maintain that the scheme rests on human rights law. Before the announcement, Council of Europe secretary general Alain Berset said countries must be able to determine migration policy, while compliance with the European convention on human rights would have to be assessed case by case. That legal test remains unresolved.









Join the conversation