Andy Burnham is expected to declare on Monday that Brexit “has not worked” and promise to sign a new agreement with the EU, provided it meets Labour’s commitments and delivers tangible improvements to everyday life.

The prime minister will make his case at the lord mayor’s banquet in the City of London before meeting European leaders at a summit this week. He says agreements covering food and farming, emissions trading and youth mobility could increase GDP by 0.4%, or about £17bn. That is a prospective gain, not an economic result already achieved.

Burnham is expected to argue that Boris Johnson failed to deliver his promise to take back control, leaving Britain with an unnecessarily hard Brexit that erected business barriers and weakened its economic potential.

“The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained,” he is due to say, repeating the judgement he made at Saturday’s Welsh Labour conference. He will liken reluctance to acknowledge Brexit’s shortcomings to the Emperor’s New Clothes.

His commitment to sign is conditional. An agreement must comply with Labour’s manifesto and government red lines, bring the settlement closer to what he says people believed they were voting for in 2016, and pass his “Makerfield test” of practical benefits in daily life. He will describe constructive co-operation over shared challenges as a “win-win”.

The proposed food arrangements also expose a distinction between influence and decision-making power. EU relations minister Hamish Falconer said on Sunday that Britain could have a “voice in the room”, but no vote on EU food policies.

Falconer said there could also be an exit clause because the EU was worried that a future Reform or Conservative government might reverse closer alignment. Previously nicknamed the “Farage clause”, it is intended to guard against costs arising from a reversal.

Those costs have a practical context: private companies, including Eurotunnel, have largely funded border infrastructure. French personnel carry out food checks there and at Calais port, with all fish checks taking place at Boulogne-sur-Mer.

Johnson, who resigned as Conservative prime minister over Partygate in 2022, argues that making Brexit a political priority is a mistake. He said Britain would “absolutely” vote to leave again if Burnham called another vote, warning: “He will impale himself and his party on this point”.

The summit has yet to settle the terms. Burnham’s promised economic benefits sit alongside unresolved questions about Britain’s influence over food rules and the cost of any future withdrawal from closer alignment.