Andy Burnham is to declare that Brexit “has not worked” and pledge to sign a new agreement with the EU, subject to conditions, before meeting European leaders at a summit this week.
The prime minister says agreements covering food and farming, emissions trading and a youth mobility scheme could increase GDP by 0.4%, or about £17bn. That is a prospective gain, rather than an economic benefit already secured.
In a speech at the lord mayor’s banquet in the City of London on Monday, Burnham is expected to argue that Boris Johnson failed to deliver his promise to take back control. He will say the UK was left with a needlessly hard Brexit that erected barriers for businesses and damaged its economic potential.
“The Brexit we were given has not worked. We have lost more than we gained,” he is expected to say, repeating the judgement he delivered at the Welsh Labour conference on Saturday. His prepared remarks compare the reluctance to acknowledge Brexit’s shortcomings to the Emperor’s New Clothes.
Burnham’s commitment to an agreement is conditional. It must respect Labour’s manifesto and the government’s red lines, improve the existing deal and bring it closer to what he says people believed they were voting for in 2016. It must also pass his “Makerfield test”: tangible improvements in everyday life.
He will describe a constructive relationship with the EU as a “win-win”, replacing confrontation with co-operation on shared challenges.
The limits of that relationship were underlined on Sunday by the EU relations minister, Hamish Falconer. He said Britain could have a “voice in the room” on EU food policies, but no vote.
Falconer also said there could well be an “exit clause” if a future British government reversed closer alignment. He said the EU was worried that a Reform or Conservative government might undo the agreement.
The negotiations therefore concern both the economic gains Burnham anticipates and the durability of closer ties: Britain could gain influence over discussions without securing a vote, while any agreement would have to account for the possibility of a later political reversal.









Join the conversation