London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Tuesday, Jul 21, 2026

Why is Hancock pushing to reform the NHS in the middle of a pandemic?

Why is Hancock pushing to reform the NHS in the middle of a pandemic?

All too often it is easier to spot someone else’s bad idea than it is our own — whether it’s shaving your head, starting a podcast, or getting back together with an ex, it can be hard to shake the idea that this time really is different, or we really are the exception for whom it’ll work out brilliantly.

All too often it is easier to spot someone else’s bad idea than it is our own — whether it’s shaving your head, starting a podcast, or getting back together with an ex, it can be hard to shake the idea that this time really is different, or we really are the exception for whom it’ll work out brilliantly.

So it is with politicians and major top-down reorganisations of the NHS. When asked about them in general terms, almost every politician from every major party will acknowledge that they usually end up being a terrible idea. They are often unpopular with NHS workers, cause a lot of pain as they are implemented, and usually end up being unpicked within a decade or so.

Despite all that, Matt Hancock has become the latest health secretary to believe that this time is different — or his ideas are different — mooting a new set of reforms to how the NHS is governed.

Unusually, Hancock’s plans would not even be unpicking the changes of a previous Labour government: the Conservatives have been in power for so long that he is proposing to undo the NHS reforms of his Conservative predecessor Andrew Lansley.

The idea should not be dismissed out of hand — just because the health service has become the UK’s secular religion shouldn’t mean politicians stop trying to improve it and make sure it works as well as it can for patients.


It’s also clear that Lansley’s reforms left much to be desired: they are notorious for having created yet more layers of bureaucracy and for making it harder for politicians to run the UK’s biggest public service — in many ways one of the key things they are elected to do.

What is baffling is why on earth Hancock would announce this kind of grand-scale reform now, when the NHS is still in the middle of handling the largest public health crisis in a century.

Intensive care units are expanded far beyond their usual capacity. Test and trace — soon to become crucial again — is still barely effective. The NHS is managing a critical vaccine roll-out, and monitoring for new strains. The health service, in other words, has its hands full already — and if Hancock wants his reforms to be effective, he should recognise the need for honest engagement and buy-in from doctors, nurses and senior NHS leaders. None of those really have time to spare right now to look to the future.

Similarly, to suggest a series of long-term reforms right now looks grimly premature when the Government has refused to announce either a preliminary or a full public inquiry into how the UK has handled coronavirus. In the long run, the most important part of such an inquiry will not be which individuals or institutions are to blame for certain mistakes, but rather what changes need to be made to make sure crises are better handled in the future — to make sure we don’t see either the unnecessarily high death toll or the larger-than-necessary economic damage we did during this crisis.

Carrying out major reforms before such an inquiry is even convened sends out all the wrong signals: it either suggests you plan to ignore whatever it concludes, or else that you will be prepared to do yet another set of reforms in just a few years’ time — in which case, why put everyone through it now? Hancock argued yesterday that the pandemic provides the rationale for his timing. In reality, it just shows the states of getting the reforms right — something which won’t be helped by rushing.

As the UK vaccination roll-out continues to be a relative success, especially compared with the EU’s, Matt Hancock is getting some recognition and positive polling for his role. It is understandable in such circumstances that he is looking for good ways to spend that political capital, and — another inevitability for any politician — looking towards whatever legacy he might leave behind.

Perhaps, though, the best legacy would be being the health secretary who resisted the urge to engage in painful NHS reforms at the wrong time — the one who had the patience to save them for when NHS staff and organisations could properly engage, and when they could incorporate the lessons from a coronavirus inquiry.

Doing nothing, for now, is sometimes the best course of action. It’s just one that British politicians find notoriously difficult.

Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
UK Universities and Industry Expand Space and Defense Research Partnerships
House of Lords Approves Social Housing Bill Amendments on Shared Ownership Rights
House of Lords Advances Civil Aviation Bill With New Passenger Protection Measures
UK Government Suspends Tariffs on Fertilizer and Food Imports to Reduce Costs
Russell Group Universities Support New UK Business Department Focused on Innovation
UK Parliament Opens Inquiry Into Transport Barriers Facing Young Jobseekers
Home Builders Federation Calls for Lower Costs as New UK Government Sets Housing Priorities
Andy Burnham Meets UK Devolved Leaders to Strengthen Regional Cooperation
Andy Burnham Holds First International Calls With Trump, Macron, and Zelenskyy
Andy Burnham Reshuffles Cabinet With John Healey Appointed Chancellor of the Exchequer
Andy Burnham Government Removes VAT From Electricity Bills to Cut Household Costs
Andy Burnham Becomes United Kingdom Prime Minister After Sir Keir Starmer Resigns
Miliband Sets Climate and International Law at Centre of UK Diplomacy
US Gasoline Returns to $4 as Renewed Iran Fighting Disrupts Oil Flows
Czech Central Bank Governor Rejects Early Euro Entry and Rate-Cut Pressure
Trump Orders 50% Tariffs on Selected Canadian Imports
Pentagon Discloses Nearly 100 US Troop Injuries During Renewed Iran Fighting
Trump Readies New Tariffs as Temporary Global Levy Nears Expiry
US Judge Pauses Paramount Skydance and Warner Bros Discovery Merger Over Antitrust Concerns
NHS England Faces Growing Retention Pressure Among Younger Midwives
UK Data Centre Expansion Faces Water and Grid Capacity Challenges
UK Defence Shares Rise After John Healey Appointment and Continued Spending Commitments
OECD Urges UK Government to Review Pension Triple Lock to Protect Public Finances
Bank of England Keeps Cautious Approach as Energy Costs Threaten Inflation Progress
County Councils Call for Wider Devolution and Long-Term Social Care Funding Reform
IMF Urges UK Government to Maintain Fiscal Discipline as Growth Forecast Slows
Russian Warship Holds Live-Fire Exercises Near UK Coast as Royal Navy Monitors Activity
Mitie Agrees Three Point One Billion Pound Takeover by OCS in Another Blow to London Listings
JPMorgan Chase Warns Bank Levies Could Hit UK Growth and Drive Capital Away
UK Unemployment Holds at Four Point Nine Percent as Labour Market Shows Resilience
UK Government Borrowing Falls Below Forecasts as Treasury Receives Early Fiscal Boost
John Healey Cuts VAT on Household Electricity Bills After Cancelling National Digital ID Scheme
Andy Burnham Forms New Labour Government With Ten-Year National Renewal Plan
EU Imposes Record €550 Million Digital Services Fine on AliExpress
UK Publishes Updated Consumption-Based Carbon Emissions Data
English Regions Prepare for Expanded Devolution and Infrastructure Powers
Russell Group Backs New Government and Calls for Stronger University-Industry Links
Bank of England Maintains Restrictive Monetary Policy Amid Persistent Inflation
Climate Progress Report Renews Debate Over the UK's Net Zero Strategy
New UK Government Launches Drive to End Rough Sleeping and Expand Social Housing
Prime Minister Andy Burnham Appoints John Healey as Chancellor in Cabinet Reshuffle
OECD Calls for Structural Reforms as UK Economy Faces Slower Growth
International Monetary Fund Expects UK Economic Growth to Slow to One Percent in 2026
Andy Burnham Takes Office as UK Prime Minister and Unveils Decade-Long Reform Agenda
London’s Housing Starts Collapse as Planning and Building Costs Stall Development
Charlie Sheen’s Daughter: "My Dad Didn’t Buy Me a House, My Breasts Bought It"
Vivienne Westwood Casts Cicciolina, 74, in Its New Autumn Campaign
Dejavu: Germany’s Military Expansion Reshapes Europe’s Strategic Balance With France
Naturally Conceived Identical Quadruplets Born in Rare Brisbane Delivery
Tate Brothers Fight British Extradition Bid After Miami Arrests
×