London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Friday, Jun 20, 2025

Powerful rural body defends Hong Kong small-house policy, takes aim at ‘busybody’

Powerful rural body defends Hong Kong small-house policy, takes aim at ‘busybody’

The Heung Yee Kuk says controversial policy allowing male indigenous villagers to build small houses is a ‘constitutionally protected’ right.

Hong Kong’s rural powerhouse, the Heung Yee Kuk, has defended the controversial policy of allowing male indigenous villagers to build small houses as a “constitutionally protected” right, telling the city’s top court it cannot be challenged by a “busybody” after an exceptional delay.

But lawyers for the appellant, Kwok Cheuk-kin, a retired civil servant who has challenged the government so many times he is nicknamed the “king of judicial reviews”, countered that the disputed policy affected everyone, considering the shortage of “decent housing”.

“Hong Kong has been waiting for so many years for someone to challenge this policy,” Martin Lee Chu-ming SC said on Tuesday, with reference to his client. “I waited, too. Everybody did. Nobody did anything until this ‘busybody’.”

Applicant Kwok Cheuk-kin outside the High Court.


The Court of Final Appeal on Tuesday heard the last round of arguments in the unprecedented constitutional challenge to the small-house policy, which confers “Ding rights” to male indigenous villagers descended from the male line to apply for building a three-storey home in villages of the New Territories.

Both the government and the kuk, which represents the villagers’ interests, have conceded that the policy is “inherently discriminatory on the grounds of social origin or birth and sex”, contrary to equality provisions in the Basic Law, the city’s mini-constitution.

At issue is whether it forms part of “the lawful traditional rights and interests of the indigenous inhabitants of the New Territories” protected by Article 40 of the Basic Law, which would render the discriminatory policy lawful and constitutional.

David Pannick QC, for the kuk, said Article 40 was a provision designed to ensure what was enjoyed before the Basic Law came into effect in 1997 would continue afterwards and be protected from challenge, provided the rights or interests concerned were lawful in 1990 when the mini-constitution was adopted.

That would include the policy, he said, given that it has been applied and enjoyed by those qualified since it was introduced by the British administration in 1972, with its validity implicitly recognised by the Sino-British Joint Declaration.

Pannick said the drafting materials of the Basic Law further showed that the policy was recognised as falling within the scope of what would become Article 40.

Those in favour of including Article 40 in the Basic Law had cited the policy as the prime example of a protected interest, he said, while those against had argued that the provision would give constitutional protection to what they described as an “arbitrary and unjustifiably discriminatory” policy.

Given that the objections had already been advanced in the drafting process, Pannick said it was “simply impermissible” to resurrect arguments by way of constitutional challenge.

“Hong Kong has been waiting for so many years for someone to challenge this policy,” lawyer Martin Lee said.


As to what qualified as “traditional”, Pannick argued that drafters were only concerned with whether contemporaneously recognised interests would be protected, adding that it could not have been their intention to require the court to act as a historian on a tracing exercise.

Pannick further argued that Kwok was “simply a busybody” who did not have sufficient standing to bring forth this challenge, given his lack of personal interest in the matter.

“He has no land in the New Territories, he has no interest in building in the New Territories,” the counsel said.

He also observed there was “exceptional delay” in instituting this judicial review, since the Basic Law had been promulgated for 24 years and counting.

Pannick said in the future the court should not entertain similar judicial reviews, where applicants lacked standing and justification for exceptional delay.

“The courts have enough to do,” he continued. “People with very real life complaints have to wait longer.”

The five-judge panel, led by Chief Justice Andrew Cheung Kui-nung, has reserved judgment.

Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
16 Billion Login Credentials Leaked in Unprecedented Cybersecurity Breach
Senate hearing on who was 'really running' Biden White House kicks off
Iranian Military Officers Reportedly Seek Contact with Reza Pahlavi, Signal Intent to Defect
FBI and Senate Investigate Allegations of Chinese Plot to Influence the 2020 Election in Biden’s Favor Using Fake U.S. Driver’s Licenses
Vietnam Emerges as Luxury Yacht Destination for Ultra‑Rich
Plans to Sell Dutch Embassy in Bangkok Face Local Opposition
China's Iranian Oil Imports Face Disruption Amid Escalating Middle East Tensions
Trump's $5 Million 'Trump Card' Visa Program Draws Nearly 70,000 Applicants
DGCA Finds No Major Safety Concerns in Air India's Boeing 787 Fleet
Airlines Reroute Flights Amid Expanding Middle East Conflict Zones
Elon Musk's xAI Seeks $9.3 Billion in Funding Amid AI Expansion
Trump Demands Iran's Unconditional Surrender Amid Escalating Conflict
Israeli Airstrike Targets Iranian State TV in Central Tehran
President Trump is leaving the G7 summit early and has ordered the National Security Council to the Situation Room
Taiwan Imposes Export Ban on Chips to Huawei and SMIC
Israel has just announced plans to strike Tehran again, and in response, Trump has urged people to evacuate
Netanyahu Signals Potential Regime Change in Iran
Juncker Criticizes EU Inaction on Trump Tariffs
EU Proposes Ban on New Russian Gas Contracts
Analysts Warn Iran May Resort to Unconventional Warfare
Iranian Regime Faces Existential Threat Amid Conflict
Energy Infrastructure Becomes War Zone in Middle East
UK Home Secretary Apologizes Over Child Grooming Failures
Trump Organization Launches 5G Mobile Network and Golden Handset
Towcester Hosts 2025 English Greyhound Derby Amid Industry Scrutiny
Gary Oldman and David Beckham Knighted in King's Birthday Honours
Over 30,000 Lightning Strikes Recorded Across UK During Overnight Storms
Princess of Wales Returns to Public Duties at Trooping the Colour
Red Arrows Use Sustainable Fuel in Historic Trooping the Colour Flypast
Former Welsh First Minister Addresses Unionist Concerns Over Irish Language
Iran Signals Openness to Nuclear Negotiations Amid Ongoing Regional Tensions
France Bars Israeli Arms Companies from Paris Defense Expo
King Charles Leads Tribute to Air India Crash Victims at Trooping the Colour
Jack Pitchford Embarks on 200-Mile Walk to Support Stem Cell Charity
Surrey Hikers Take on Challenge of Climbing 11 Peaks in a Single Day
UK Deploys RAF Jets to Middle East Amid Israel-Iran Tensions
Two Skydivers Die in 'Tragic Accident' at Devon Airfield
Sainsbury's and Morrisons Accused of Displaying Prohibited Tobacco Ads
UK Launches National Inquiry into Grooming Gangs
Families Seek Closure After Air India Crash
Gold Emerges as Global Safe Haven Amid Uncertainty
Trump Reports $57 Million Earnings from Crypto Venture
Trump's Military Parade Sparks Concerns Over Authoritarianism
Nationwide 'No Kings' Protests Challenge Trump's Leadership
UK Deploys Jets to Middle East Amid Rising Tensions
Trump's Anti-War Stance Tested Amid Israel-Iran Conflict
Germany Holds First Veterans Celebration Since WWII
U.S. Health Secretary Dismisses CDC Vaccine Advisory Committee
Minnesota Lawmaker Melissa Hortman and Husband Killed in Targeted Attack; Senator John Hoffman and Wife Injured
Exiled Iranian Prince Reza Pahlavi Urges Overthrow of Khamenei Regime
×