Lidl wins court battle with Tesco over use of yellow circle on Clubcard branding
The UK's largest retailer says it plans to appeal the High Court ruling which found it had taken "unfair advantage" of Lidl's distinctive reputation for low prices.
Lidl has won a trademark lawsuit against grocery market leader Tesco over its use of a yellow circle in branding.
The German discount chain brought the case in 2020 shortly after its rival adopted a yellow circle against a blue background to promote its Clubcard Prices discount scheme.
Lidl has traditionally used a yellow circle on a blue background in its main logo.
Tesco's Clubcard Price scheme is deployed in the retailer's stores, sometimes next to specific discounted products as well as more generally to promote the scheme.
Judge Joanna Smith, sitting at the High Court, said in a written ruling that Tesco had "taken unfair advantage of the distinctive reputation" for low prices held by Lidl's trademarks.
However, she rejected Lidl's argument that Tesco had "the deliberate subjective intention of riding on Lidl's coat tails".
It marked a rare victory for the discounter over its largest rival though, like Aldi, Lidl has been eating away at the dominant market shares of the big four supermarket chains for years.
A Lidl spokesperson said of the ruling: "We are pleased that the court has agreed with us and that it will now order Tesco to stop using the Clubcard logo."
Tesco said it planned to appeal.
"We are surprised and disappointed by the decision today in relation to the claim brought by Lidl against our Clubcard Prices logo," a statement said.
Charlotte Duly, head of brand protection at the law firm Charles Russell Speechlys, said the case would have cost millions of pounds
"Lidl relied on survey evidence to show consumer perception of their wordless logo," she said.
"Tesco objected to this, and whilst undertaking a survey that complies with the requirements set down in case law can be difficult and onerous leading to an increase in costs for both parties, the survey was admitted into the proceedings.
"Lidl has won as the court agrees that Tesco has taken unfair advantage of the reputation in Lidl's logos, even if this was not deliberate - a landmark decision between two major brands.
"From both a general interest perspective and a legal point of view, there are a number of very interesting issues raised in this case and it will be interesting to see whether this judgment triggers more cases of this kind."
The German discount chain brought the case in 2020 shortly after its rival adopted a yellow circle against a blue background to promote its Clubcard Prices discount scheme.
Lidl has traditionally used a yellow circle on a blue background in its main logo.
Tesco's Clubcard Price scheme is deployed in the retailer's stores, sometimes next to specific discounted products as well as more generally to promote the scheme.
Judge Joanna Smith, sitting at the High Court, said in a written ruling that Tesco had "taken unfair advantage of the distinctive reputation" for low prices held by Lidl's trademarks.
However, she rejected Lidl's argument that Tesco had "the deliberate subjective intention of riding on Lidl's coat tails".
It marked a rare victory for the discounter over its largest rival though, like Aldi, Lidl has been eating away at the dominant market shares of the big four supermarket chains for years.
A Lidl spokesperson said of the ruling: "We are pleased that the court has agreed with us and that it will now order Tesco to stop using the Clubcard logo."
Tesco said it planned to appeal.
"We are surprised and disappointed by the decision today in relation to the claim brought by Lidl against our Clubcard Prices logo," a statement said.
Charlotte Duly, head of brand protection at the law firm Charles Russell Speechlys, said the case would have cost millions of pounds
"Lidl relied on survey evidence to show consumer perception of their wordless logo," she said.
"Tesco objected to this, and whilst undertaking a survey that complies with the requirements set down in case law can be difficult and onerous leading to an increase in costs for both parties, the survey was admitted into the proceedings.
"Lidl has won as the court agrees that Tesco has taken unfair advantage of the reputation in Lidl's logos, even if this was not deliberate - a landmark decision between two major brands.
"From both a general interest perspective and a legal point of view, there are a number of very interesting issues raised in this case and it will be interesting to see whether this judgment triggers more cases of this kind."
