London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Saturday, Nov 22, 2025

What the UK can teach the U.S. (again)

What the UK can teach the U.S. (again)

Political trends in the United States and Great Britain often seem to move in parallel, and last week’s local elections across the United Kingdom yield some pertinent lessons for U.S. political parties.
For Republicans, the main takeaway is that competent governance matters. One big reason Britain’s Conservatives scored major gains on “Super Thursday” is that voters credit Prime Minister Boris Johnson with having done a good job of rolling out COVID vaccines.

In contrast, Donald Trump bungled the pandemic from start to finish in a clownish performance that his own pollster has cited as the number one reason U.S. voters denied him reelection in 2020.

For Democrats, the sad state of Britain’s Labour Party is a cautionary tale against what can happen to progressives when they abandon electoral pragmatism and indulge left-wing purists. The party seems unable to exorcise the ghost of ex-leader Jeremy Corbyn, the doctrinaire socialist who led the party two years ago to its worst drubbing since the 1930s.

The biggest story last week was Labour’s humiliating loss of Hartlepool, a classic blue-collar constituency, for the first time since the 1940s. It confirmed the Tories’ growing strength, post-Brexit, among working-class voters in Labour’s strongholds in the industrial north and Midlands. As UK political analyst Matthew Goodwin has pointed out, Hartlepool is the 55th seat that Conservatives have wrested from Labour in just the last two years. All but four of them were pro-Brexit in 2016.

The other big winner in last week’s voting was the Scottish National Party, led by Nicola Sturgeon. The SNP won 64 seats, just one shy of a majority in the Scottish Parliament, with the Tories and Labour trailing far behind.

This is a bad omen for both parties and indeed anyone who doesn’t want to see the UK unravel. Sturgeon has promised to press the Scottish Parliament for a second vote on independence. The first, in 2015, failed by a 10-point margin. But Scottish voters were cool to Brexit and, given its nationalist agenda the SNP’s gains in recent elections — mostly at Labour’s expense — presumably indicate rising separatist sentiment.

The Tories benefitted last week not only from the government’s successful vaccine push, but also from having finally ended the Brexit imbroglio that had convulsed British politics for nearly four years. Johnson also is cleverly preempting Labour by renouncing his party’s previous austerity stance and promising to spend lustily on infrastructure, National Health and other public services.

By getting Brexit done and moving left on economics, Johnson has taken the wind out of the nationalist right’s sails even as the Tories appropriate Labour’s historic working-class base.

That puts Labour in a double bind. It is losing the north and Midlands to the Tories, and losing Scotland to the SNP. Where will Labour find the 125 or so seats it will need to win the next national election?

Its new leader, Kier Starmer, is in an uneviable position. Peter Mandelson, a top New Labour strategist and protégé of Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, formerly held the Hartlepool seat. He told the BBC that while campaigning there, he heard little about Brexit — but a lot about Corbyn, who “is still casting a very dark cloud over Labour.”

Starmer’s challenge is to signal a departure from Corbynism without provoking a fatal rupture with young urban progressives and old unionists who still control the party apparatus. Many adore Corbyn’s uncompromising radicalism in the same way that their U.S. counterparts adore Sen. Bernie Sanders.

But Starmer’s efforts to define a new Labour vision around “devolution and social justice” haven’t gained traction. A common complaint among voters was that they don’t know where the party stands anymore.

Labour has yet to confront the reality of a realignment of UK politics around questions of national and cultural identity rather than the familiar left-right axis. Class warfare between capital and labor — historically Labour’s bread and butter — has taken a back seat to a clash of values that divides the UK along lines of education, age and geography.

This dramatic shift in the basic terms of political debate, contends Goodwin, has voters asking, “what’s the point of the Labour Party?”

The parallels between Labour and the Democrats, of course, aren’t exact. The latter, after all, chose the pragmatically liberal Biden rather than the dogmatic Sanders as their standard-bearer.

But both parties confront the challenge of working-class alienation, with Democrats suffering slippage in 2020 among blue-collar Hispanic and blacks. Both need to tackle the fears of cultural and economic displacement that manifest themselves in polarizing debates over immigration, nationalism and the officious policing of thoughts by “woke” proponents of identitarian politics. And both need to reach beyond their base of educated, urban and relatively affluent young professionals to win elections and govern.

As progressive parties, both risk losing their political soul if they lose touch with the aspirations and values of ordinary working people. Fortunately for Democrats, Biden intuitively grasps that danger, even if the progressives constantly pressuring him to move left don’t.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Maduro Tightens Security Measures as U.S. Strike Threat Intensifies
U.S. Envoys Deliver Ultimatum to Ukraine: Sign Peace Deal by Thursday or Risk Losing American Support
Zelenskyy Signals Progress Toward Ending the War: ‘One of the Hardest Moments in History’ (end of his business model?)
U.S. Issues Alert Declaring Venezuelan Airspace a Hazard Due to Escalating Security Conditions
The U.S. State Department Announces That Mass Migration Constitutes an Existential Threat to Western Civilization and Undermines the Stability of Key American Allies
Students Challenge AI-Driven Teaching at University of Staffordshire
Pikeville Medical Center Partners with UK’s Golisano Children’s Network to Expand Pediatric Care
Germany, France and UK Confirm Full Support for Ukraine in US-Backed Security Plan
UK Low-Traffic Neighbourhoods Face Rising Backlash as Pandemic Schemes Unravel
UK Records Coldest Night of Autumn as Sub-Zero Conditions Sweep the Country
UK at Risk of Losing International Doctors as Workforce Exodus Grows, Regulator Warns
ASU Launches ASU London, Extending Its Innovation Brand to the UK Education Market
UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer to Visit China in January as Diplomatic Reset Accelerates
Google Launches Voluntary Buyouts for UK Staff Amid AI-Driven Company Realignment
UK braces for freezing snap as snow and ice warnings escalate
Majority of UK Novelists Fear AI Could Displace Their Work, Cambridge Study Finds
UK's Carrier Strike Group Achieves Full Operational Capability During NATO Drill in Mediterranean
Trump and Mamdani to Meet at the White House: “The Communist Asked”
Nvidia Again Beats Forecasts, Shares Jump in After-Hours Trading
Wintry Conditions Persist Along UK Coasts After Up to Seven Centimetres of Snow
UK Inflation Eases to 3.6 % in October, Opening Door for Rate Cut
UK Accelerates Munitions Factory Build-Out to Reinforce Warfighting Readiness
UK Consumer Optimism Plunges Ahead of November Budget
A Decade of Innovation Stagnation at Apple: The Cook Era Critique
Caribbean Reparations Commission Seeks ‘Mutually Beneficial’ Justice from UK
EU Insists UK Must Contribute Financially for Access to Electricity Market and Broader Ties
UK to Outlaw Live-Event Ticket Resales Above Face Value
President Donald Trump Hosts Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman at White House to Seal Major Defence and Investment Deals
German Entertainment Icons Alice and Ellen Kessler Die Together at Age 89
UK Unveils Sweeping Asylum Reforms with 20-Year Settlement Wait and Conditional Status
UK Orders Twitter Hacker to Repay £4.1 Million Following 2020 High-Profile Breach
Popeyes UK Eyes Century Mark as Fried-Chicken Chain Accelerates Roll-out
Two-thirds of UK nurses report working while unwell amid staffing crisis
Britain to Reform Human-Rights Laws in Sweeping Asylum Policy Overhaul
Nearly Half of Job Losses Under Labour Government Affect UK Youth
UK Chancellor Reeves Eyes High-Value Home Levy in Budget to Raise Tens of Billions
UK Urges Poland to Choose Swedish Submarines in Multi-Billion € Defence Bid
US Border Czar Tom Homan Declares UK No Longer a ‘Friend’ Amid Intelligence Rift
UK Announces Reversal of Income Tax Hike Plans Ahead of Budget
Starmer Faces Mounting Turmoil as Leaked Briefings Ignite Leadership Plot Rumours
UK Commentator Sami Hamdi Returns Home After US Visa Revocation and Detention
UK Eyes Denmark-Style Asylum Rules in Major Migration Shift
UK Signals Intelligence Freeze Amid US Maritime Drug-Strike Campaign
TikTok Awards UK & Ireland 2025 Celebrates Top Creators Including Max Klymenko as Creator of the Year
UK Growth Nearly Stalls at 0.1% in Q3 as Cyberattack Halts Car Production
Apple Denied Permission to Appeal UK App Store Ruling, Faces Over £1bn Liability
UK Chooses Wylfa for First Small Modular Reactors, Drawing Sharp U.S. Objection
Starmer Faces Growing Labour Backlash as Briefing Sparks Authority Crisis
Reform UK Withdraws from BBC Documentary Amid Legal Storm Over Trump Speech Edit
UK Prime Minister Attempts to Reassert Authority Amid Internal Labour Leadership Drama
×