Mahmood orders police impartiality standard to address falling trust
Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has commissioned a new police impartiality standard, arguing that falling public trust requires forces to address both misconduct and perceptions that the law is applied differently to different people.
In her speech to the 2026 NPCC/APCC summit, she criticised previous anti-racism guidance and some forces’ engagement with political campaigners, while insisting that racism and misogyny within policing still required action. She also announced a leadership fast stream and plans for around 200 Local Police Commands across England and Wales.
The College of Policing will develop the impartiality standard, with consultation due early in the new year. Mahmood said it would explain how impartiality should work when policing events, using symbols that might carry political connotations, engaging with communities and treating victims and offenders without prejudice, favouritism or discrimination.
Her argument rested on a contrast: she said crime was falling and officers continued to show exceptional courage, yet confidence in policing had weakened.
According to the figures she cited, violent crime was at its lowest level since records began in 1981. Since the government took office, she said, knife crime had fallen by 11%, gun crime by 18% and homicide by 7%. Acquisitive offences, including shop theft, were also beginning to decline.
Against that, Mahmood said trust and confidence had fallen by 8% and 12% respectively over the past decade. She contrasted those declines with a history of high trust, when eight in ten people had said their local police could be trusted.
Invoking the Peelian principle that police powers depend on public approval, she argued that policing by consent could not endure without trust. She identified three public expectations: high standards among officers, impartial enforcement and forces capable of handling the crimes they face.
On impartiality, Mahmood said the vast majority of officers applied the law fairly. She nevertheless argued that examples of differential treatment had damaged policing and allowed others to promote what she described as the false idea that Britain had two-tier policing.
She drew a distinction between problems arising from the law and those arising from enforcement. The government was responsible for resolving legal inconsistency or uncertainty, she said, while police leaders had to address failures in how the law was applied.
Lord Macdonald’s review of public order and hate crime laws, commissioned the previous year, would be published soon alongside the government’s response.
Mahmood’s sharpest criticism concerned the former Police Anti-Racism Commitment. She acknowledged that it had sought to tackle racism but argued that its wording had undermined that purpose. She objected to its statement that fair policing “does not mean treating everyone the same” and its advice that officers should not be “colourblind”.
In her assessment, the document had reinforced perceptions of unequal treatment rather than improving confidence. The speech offered her criticism of the guidance, rather than a response from its authors.
Mahmood also argued that some forces had moved beyond community engagement into politics by working with activist groups and single-issue campaigners. Engagement should concentrate on residents and local concerns, she said, rather than learning campaign language or relying on organisations pursuing political objectives.
She contrasted that approach with the Peelian requirement for “Absolutely impartial service to the law, in complete independence of policy.” She also criticised what she saw as excessive complexity and the influence of intellectual movements originating on American university campuses.
At the same time, she said discrimination remained a problem. As a Muslim Home Secretary representing one of the country’s most diverse constituencies, she said equality mattered personally to her. She condemned racism and misogyny at Charing Cross police station and noted that, more than 30 years after Stephen Lawrence’s murder, the proportion of black officers remained virtually unchanged at little more than 1%.
Her proposed answer was consistent enforcement without fear or favour, rather than differential treatment intended to correct inequality.
Misconduct and leadership formed the other central strands of the speech. Mahmood said there had been 16,000 allegations of police misconduct in the year ending March 2025, 20% more than in the previous year. Those figures concerned allegations, not findings against every officer involved.
She cited 15 officers found guilty of gross misconduct at Charing Cross after an investigation exposed the station’s culture. She also referred to WhatsApp groups at Cambridgeshire Police, where a former sergeant had been found guilty of misconduct, 12 other officers had been investigated and two had been convicted of misconduct in public office.
The government had strengthened misconduct procedures, she said, introducing a presumption of dismissal for gross misconduct and mandatory suspension for officers charged with domestic abuse or sexual offences. Vetting had also become a statutory requirement for the first time, giving forces powers to dismiss officers who failed the checks.
Mahmood told police leaders that they were responsible for using those powers. She acknowledged the determination and courage required to confront misconduct and argued that senior officers set standards throughout their forces.
She linked those problems to weaknesses in leadership development identified by Lord Blunkett and Lord Herbert’s Police Leadership Commission, which reported in the summer. Its findings, she said, showed inconsistent and sometimes inadequate leadership.
In July, eight serving or former chief constables were under investigation for misconduct, she said. At one point, a force had three chiefs because two were simultaneously suspended while under investigation. The previous year, nine chief constable vacancies had attracted only 23 applicants.
To strengthen the pipeline of senior officers, Mahmood announced a fast-stream programme starting next year. It would recruit up to 200 people annually from inside and outside policing, placing them on a five- to ten-year route to superintendent. The government was considering all the commission’s recommendations and would publish a full response soon.
The speech also paid tribute to officers whose actions had protected the public. Mahmood recalled meeting Police Bravery Awards nominees at 10 Downing Street a few months earlier, including PC Yasmin Mechem-Whitfield, who attended with her mother.
Two years before that meeting, Mechem-Whitfield had pursued an armed killer through Hainault with little more than a Taser and PAVA spray. He attacked her with a knife, causing life-changing injuries. Mahmood said her bravery, alongside that of Inspector Moloy Campbell and PC Cameron King, had undoubtedly saved lives.
She also praised Surrey Police’s PC Jay Wakefield, who pulled an unconscious driver from a burning vehicle through thick smoke and intense heat, moments before it exploded. In another incident reported to her in recent weeks, an off-duty inspector had taken her children to safety before running towards an attacker at an Underground station, arresting him and asking members of the public to help restrain him until officers arrived.
Mahmood argued that such acts deserved recognition but did not remove the need for institutional change. Turning to force structures dating from the 1960s, she said forces of differing sizes were being pulled between local policing, specialist investigations and, often, national responsibilities. Her case for restructuring was that those competing demands were preventing forces from being set up to succeed.