London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Friday, Oct 02, 2026

Trump's new 'birth tourism' policy is already law in Hong Kong

Trump's new 'birth tourism' policy is already law in Hong Kong

Under President Trump’s new regulation, consular officers will be able to deny visas to pregnant women hoping to give birth in U.S. hospitals.
The first public opinion poll responding to President Donald Trump’s new policy to control “birth tourism” has just been released and it shows that the move is popular among voters. Even though elite media have been tearing it down as a “way to control women,” public support for the policy shouldn’t be surprising.

Ever since an administrative change by State Department bureaucrats in 1967, the U.S. has been operating under a policy of “birthright citizenship” which awards passports to almost any infant born on American soil no matter what their parents’ immigration status.

Under President Trump’s new regulation, however, consular officers will have the ability to deny visas to pregnant women hoping to give birth in U.S. hospitals. The effort will likely stop many of the more than 30,000 (mostly Chinese) birth tourists who come here annually to take advantage of the policy.

U.S. citizens as well as immigrants who got here by complying with our immigration laws have long expressed frustration over what they see as a giant loophole in the system that needs closing. Still, Sen. Bob Menendez (D-N.J.), one of the Democrats’ louder proponents for mass migration, rejected Trump’s move based on the claim that it is “often advanced by nativist, restrictionist groups.” This is the kind of cheap, lazy and divisive -not to mention wrong -rhetoric that dismisses the views of large segments of the American public.

While immigration reform on many fronts has been a foundation of the Trump presidency, the White House likely got its inspiration from a place that implemented the exact same policy a few years back and with which Menendez is supposed to be well acquainted: Hong Kong.

Hong Kong was one of the last developed parts of the world to curb birthright citizenship, and it did so in a way nearly identical to what the White House recently announced. As the ranking member of the Foreign Relations Committee and a lead sponsor of the anti-Beijing “Hong Kong Human Rights and Democracy Act,” Menendez should know the role which birth-tourism abuse -and Chinese immigration in general -has played in the ongoing tensions between the two regions.

Similar to the violent “umbrella protests” in 2014, the local anger being witnessed today is closely tied to the issue, almost as much as the extradition treaty which sparked the current round protests.

Since 1997, when the then-British colony of Hong Kong reverted back to Beijing, close to 1.5 million mandarin-speaking Mainland Chinese have migrated to the small, dense, majority-Cantonese-speaking region. Numbering just a few percent when the handover happened, Mainlanders (who are viewed by Hong Kongers as being rude, noisy and gauche) now represent close to one-fifth of Hong Kong’s 7.5 million population. Adding to the resentment is Beijing’s near total control over the number of immigration permits given out to Mainlanders and Hong Kong’s inability to change the status quo.

For reasons familiar to most Americans, Mainlander migration has actually long been a source of tension in Hong Kong. According to its post-handover constitution, if a Mainland woman happens to give birth in Hong Kong, her child becomes entitled to birthright citizenship and an automatic right to a Hong Kong passport. Hong Kong citizenship is coveted by Mainlanders because of the access it provides to the local welfare, medical care, education system as well as easier international travel.

But after years of stories in the media about local hospitals being overrun by Mainland would-be mothers, tensions finally boiled over in 2010 when local residents took to the streets in protest. As a result, the Hong Kong government created a law, similar to the new Trump policy, denying entry to those pregnant Mainland women failing to show proof of obstetric appointments in the city and jailing those caught making false claims about their intentions at the border.

Local people, however, are still complaining about Mainlanders overcrowding local hospitals as well as the pressure put on Hong Kong’s welfare system from their mass migration. As a result, local lawmakers have proposed that Hong Kong try to assert greater authority over permit approvals, including a cut to overall numbers and a requirement that applicants prove financial independence before being allowed to immigrate.

These same worries, of course, have also played out in the U.S.; hence, the president’s newly Supreme Court-approved five-year moratorium on welfare use for those hoping to permanently immigrate here. Menendez and other Democratic senators predictably say the policy “frightens people away from critical resources” and “compromises families and communities.”

Few in the world today know the sanctity of national sovereignty and self-rule like the people of Hong Kong. Every day, working- and middle-class Hong Kongers feel the effects wrought on their nation’s quality of life by an immigration system almost completely outside their control.

This is what birthright citizenship is doing in the U.S.: It removes from American citizens their sovereign choice over who and how many can enter the country. The president has taken one small but important step in restoring that.

Dale Wilcox is executive director and general counsel at the Immigration Reform Law Institute, a public interest law firm working to defend the rights and interests of the American people from the negative effects of illegal migration.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
UK Councils to Receive Sweeping Planning Powers to Ban New Vape and Betting Shops
Chancellor John Healey Faces Tax and Pension Scrutiny Ahead of Autumn Budget
Metropolitan Police Apologise for Accidental Disclosure in High-Profile Investigation
UK Universities Report Record International Enrolment as Housing Pressure Grows
UK Logistics Firms Monitor Rhine Disruption as Low Water Threatens European Supply Chains
UK Food Industry Warns Inflation Could Approach 7%
UK Introduces Vaping Duty and Mandatory Retail Stamps
Scotland Raises Property Taxes and Expands Child Payment in Annual Budget
Greggs Plans Four Factory Closures With 740 Jobs at Risk
OECD Raises UK 2026 Growth Forecast to 1.1%
UK Inflation Rises to 3.1% as Bank of England Faces Rate Debate
Andy Burnham Criticises Brexit and Says Rejoining EU Single Market Remains an Option
UK Imposes New Sanctions on Russian Military Networks and Propagandists
UK Launches Nationwide Early-Release Prison Scheme
Andy Burnham Says Security Services See Signs of Iranian Involvement in RAF Fairford Incident
Manchester City Found Guilty on Premier League Financial Charges After Independent Investigation
Scottish Court to Rule on Bid to Force No-Confidence Vote Against Aberdeen Council Co-Leader
UK Bans Extra Charges for Seating Children Under 12 Beside Accompanying Adults
UK Introduces Vaping Duty and New Licensing Requirements
Greggs to Close Four UK Factories and Cut 740 Jobs
Hundreds of Prisoners Released Early as England and Wales Prisons Reach 98% Capacity
UK Unveils New Russia Sanctions Targeting War Funding and Shadow Fleet
Burnham Says There Are Strong Indications of Iranian Involvement in RAF Fairford Security Breach
Prime Minister Andy Burnham Raises Prospect of Reviewing Britain's Post-Brexit EU Relationship
Markets Price in Bank of England Rate Increases as Inflation Rises to 3.1%
UK Borrowing Costs Climb Toward 5.5% as Global Bond Sell-Off Intensifies
UK-France One-In-One-Out Migration Agreement Expires as London Seeks Alternative Measures
Southwest England Faces Flood Alerts After Heavy Autumn Storms
UK Expands Funding for Rapid Electric Vehicle Charging Infrastructure
Welsh Government Approves Funding to Upgrade South Wales Transport
Northern Ireland Tensions Rise as Orange Order Rejects Drumcree Compromise
NHS Leaders Back Early Design of Proposed National Care Service
More Than One-Third of Regional UK Universities Face Financial Deficits
UK Current Account Deficit Narrows as Cross-Border Financial Flows Remain Strong
Bank of England and FCA Issue New Rules for Stablecoins and Digital Assets
MI5 Warns UK Universities Over Research Links With Chinese Institutions
UK Energy Price Cap Rises 4% as Electricity VAT Is Temporarily Suspended
Equity Calls for UK Personality Rights to Protect Performers From AI Replication
OpenAI Pauses Advanced Model Training Following Safety Concerns
Scottish Government Proposes Replacing 32 Councils With Larger Regional Authorities
Ofgem Raises UK Household Energy Price Cap by 4% From October
UK Counter-Terrorism Police Continue Investigation After Five Arrests Near RAF Fairford
OECD Cuts UK 2027 Growth Forecast to 1%
Labour Says State Pension Triple Lock Remains Protected Through Current Parliament
Andy Burnham Pledges National Care Service With Free Social Care in England
Six Flags Permanently Shuts Landmark X2 Roller Coaster Following Safety Scandals
Metropolitan Police Rule Out Terrorism in Golders Green Stabbing Investigation
Lithium-Ion Battery Identified as Cause of Fatal Merseyside House Fire
UK Department Rejects New Sea Use Framework Due to Stakeholder Fatigue
Major Thames Water Pipe Burst Causes School Closures in London
×