London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Thursday, Jul 10, 2025

Top British judges give vote of confidence to Hong Kong’s judicial independence

Top British judges give vote of confidence to Hong Kong’s judicial independence

Supreme Court president Robert Reed and deputy Patrick Hodge announce they will stay on as non-permanent judges on city’s Court of Final Appeal.

Two of Britain’s top judges have given a strong vote of confidence to Hong Kong’s judicial independence, announcing that they will continue serving at the city’s highest court.

British Supreme Court president Robert Reed on Friday said he and his deputy, Patrick Hodge, would carry on as non-permanent judges at Hong Kong’s Court of Final Appeal, as they had concluded that the city’s judiciary had continued to act largely independently of the government after the enactment of the Beijing-imposed national security law more than a year ago.

The announcement was a U-turn for Lord Justice Reed after indicating in March that he might quit, should he conclude the city’s judicial independence had been compromised.

“I have been closely monitoring and assessing developments in Hong Kong, in discussion with the foreign secretary and the lord chancellor,” he said on Friday. “Together, we have been reviewing the operation of the agreement under which UK judges have served there since 1997 in the light of those developments.

“At this time, our shared assessment is that the judiciary in Hong Kong continues to act largely independently of government and their decisions continue to be consistent with the rule of law.”

Patrick Hodge (left) and Robert Reed said there was still widespread support in Hong Kong for the participation of British judges.


Reed also noted that there was still widespread support among the legal community in Hong Kong for the participation of British and other overseas judges in the work of the Court of Final Appeal.

“Under these circumstances, Lord Hodge and I remain engaged in the Court of Final Appeal with the full support of the foreign secretary and the lord chancellor,” he said.

“I will continue to assess the position in Hong Kong as it develops, in discussion with the UK government.”

Reed will preside remotely over two appeal cases on August 31 and September 2 through video conferencing. Hodge is scheduled to sit later this year.

Since China’s top legislative body imposed the national security law on Hong Kong in June last year to ban acts of secession, subversion, terrorism and collusion with foreign forces, there has been fierce debate among legal circles in both the city and Britain on whether foreign judges should continue to serve at the Court of Final Appeal.

The new law has empowered the city’s leader to designate judges to hear national security cases, sparking concerns as to whether this would allow interference in the work of the judiciary.

Citing undisclosed reasons relating to the national security law, Justice James Spigelman from Australia last September became the first foreign judge to resign from Hong Kong’s top court.

In June, a former top British judge, Baroness Brenda Hale, also said she would quit the Court of Final Appeal when her first term expired in July.

But Lord Jonathan Sumption, one of the British judges on the bench, asserted in March that calls for the withdrawal of foreign judges were merely part of a “political boycott” and made clear he intended to continue serving at the Court of Final Appeal.

In May, former chief justice Geoffrey Ma Tao-li defended the role of foreign judges in the city, arguing they should continue to sit on the bench and help enforce the mini-constitution which he described as the basis of judicial independence.

Baroness Brenda Hale.


Former Bar Association chairman Alan Leong Kah-kit SC, chairman of the opposition Civic Party, welcomed Friday’s statement, but noted that Reed had stopped short of extending his full support for Hong Kong’s top court.

“Lord Reed’s statement was cautiously guarded in describing decisions of the Hong Kong judiciary as acting largely independently of government and consistent with the rule of law,” he said.

“Read together with the last paragraph which emphasised on a continuous assessment of the Hong Kong position as it developed, it is an affirmation of his and other UK judges’ role as ‘canaries in a coal mine’, namely, if judicial independence and autonomy are further compromised, there could come a day when these canaries would abandon the coal mine so as to warn those concerned that there was danger.”

He added: “There remain lawyers and judges in Hong Kong who are still trying our utmost to uphold the core values of the rule of law, and the law lords’ decision to stay is certainly a booster to our morale.

“At the same time, their decision to stay is no reason for the government to be complacent.”

Reed said their decision had the full support of Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab, which former Bar Association chairman Ronny Tong Ka-wah found surprising given the minister had previously questioned whether the country’s jurists should continue to serve on the city’s courts.

Pro-establishment lawmakers also applauded the decision.

“Our judiciary has remained intact, and applied the law independently. Even though the security law is quite new and judges are not too familiar with it yet, they have tried their best,” legislator and lawyer Paul Tse Wai-chun said.

“This decision is a very good reference for other judges, and Hong Kong authorities should go all out in promoting this, not just issuing some statement to repeat jargon.”

Tse expressed hope that the development indicated Sino-British ties would improve, even as Washington’s international reputation was tarnished by its disastrous withdrawal from Afghanistan.

Legislator Holden Chow Ho-ding, also a lawyer and a deputy leader of the Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong, said Reed had spoken the truth in acknowledging the city’s long-standing judicial independence and robust rule of law.

“I hope other foreign politicians will also reverse course and abandon their way of smearing our ‘one country, two systems’,” he said, referring to the governing principle under which Hong Kong is guaranteed a high degree of autonomy.

The Court of Final Appeal currently has 12 non-permanent judges from other common law jurisdictions.


Barrister Eunice Yung Hoi-yan, vice-chairwoman of the New People’s Party, hailed the “professional judgment” of the top British jurists.

“National security laws are not unique to Hong Kong – the US and other countries have similar laws – and now the international community has cast a vote of confidence in Hong Kong’s application of the law, and its rule of law,” she said. “There are good reasons for foreign judges to stay in the Hong Kong court.”

The judiciary issued a statement in response to the British judges’ move.

“[We are] an independent judiciary that upholds the rule of law. This is clearly prescribed under the Basic Law,” it said.

“As required by their judicial oath, all judges and judicial officers of the Hong Kong judiciary exercise their judicial powers and decide cases independently in accordance with the law.”

The Court of Final Appeal currently has 12 non-permanent judges from other common law jurisdictions – eight from Britain, three from Australia and one from Canada.

“Their participation in the Court of Final Appeal helps Hong Kong to maintain its links with other common law jurisdictions and enhances public confidence in Hong Kong’s judicial system,” the judiciary’s statement said. “Their immense contribution to the work of the Court of Final Appeal has repeatedly been acknowledged.”

Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
US Imposes New Tariffs on Brazilian Exports Amid Political Tensions
Azerbaijan and Armenia are on the brink of a historic peace deal.
Emails Leaked: How Passenger Luggage Became a Side Income for Airport Workers
Polish MEP: “Dear Leftists - China is laughing at you, Russia is laughing, India is laughing”
BRICS Expands Membership with Indonesia and Ten New Partner Countries
Weinstein Victim’s Lawyer Says MeToo Movement Still Strong
U.S. Enacts Sweeping Tax and Spending Legislation Amid Trade Policy Shifts
Football Mourns as Diogo Jota and Brother André Silva Laid to Rest in Portugal
Labour Expected to Withdraw Support for Special Needs Funding Model
Leaked Audio Reveals Tory Aide Defending DEI Record
Elon Musk Founds a Party Following a Poll on X: "You Wanted It – You Got It!"
London Stock Exchange Faces Historic Low in Initial Public Offerings
A new online platform has emerged in the United Kingdom, specifically targeting Muslim men seeking virgin brides
Trump Celebrates Independence Day with B-2 Flyover and Signs Controversial Legislation
Boris Johnson Urges Conservatives to Ignore Farage
SNP Ordered to Update Single-Sex Space Guidance Within Days
Starmer Set to Reject Calls for Wealth Taxes
Stolen Century-Old Rolls-Royce Recovered After Hotel Theft
Macron Presses Starmer to Recognise Palestinian State
Labour Delayed Palestine Action Ban Over Riot Concerns
Swinney’s Tax Comments ‘Offensive to Scots’, Say Tories
High Street Retailers to Enforce Bans on Serial Shoplifters
Music Banned by Henry VIII to Be Performed After 500 Years
Steve Coogan Says Working Class Is Being ‘Ethnically Cleansed’
Home Office Admits Uncertainty Over Visa Overstayer Numbers
JD Vance Questions Mandelson Over Reform Party’s Rising Popularity
Macron to Receive Windsor Carriage Ride in Royal Gesture
Labour Accused of ‘Hammering’ Scots During First Year in Power
BBC Head of Music Stood Down Amid Bob Vylan Controversy
Corbyn Eyes Hard-Left Challenge to Starmer’s Leadership
London Tube Trains Suspended After Major Fire Erupts Nearby
Richard Kemp: I Felt Safer in Israel Under Attack Than in the UK
Cyclist Says Police Cited Human Rights Act for Riding No-Handed
China’s Central Bank Consults European Peers on Low-Rate Strategies
AI Raises Alarms Over Long-Term Job Security
Saudi Arabia Maintains Ties with Iran Despite Israel Conflict
Musk Battles to Protect Tesla Amid Trump Policy Threats
Air France-KLM Acquires Majority Stake in Scandinavian Airlines
UK Educators Sound Alarm on Declining Child Literacy
Shein Fined €40 Million in France Over Misleading Discounts
Brazil’s Lula Visits Kirchner During Argentina House Arrest
Trump Scores Legislative Win as House Passes Tax Reform Bill
Keir Starmer Faces Criticism After Rocky First Year in Power
DJI Launches Heavy-Duty Coaxial Quadcopter with 80 kg Lift Capacity
U.S. Senate Approves Major Legislation Dubbed the 'Big Beautiful Bill'
Largest Healthcare Fraud Takedown in U.S. History Announced by DOJ
Poland Implements Border Checks Amid Growing Migration Tensions
Political Dispute Escalates Between Trump and Musk
Emirates Airline Expands Market Share with New $20 Million Campaign
Amazon Reaches Milestone with Deployment of One Millionth Robot
×