Family say father died in agony after repeated pleas for pain relief
Bharat Gharu’s relatives describe unanswered pleas for help; the ambulance service acknowledges failings, while the hospital trust defends his treatment.
The family of a father of five who died in severe pain from pancreatic cancer say repeated pleas for help went unanswered during his final hours. London Ambulance Service has apologised for shortcomings in his care and communication, while the hospital trust has defended his treatment.
Bharat Gharu, 71, died on 16 March 2025 after collapsing at home, six weeks after being diagnosed with stage four cancer. His daughter, Careena Gharu, says he was left screaming in pain at home, in an ambulance and in a hospital corridor before dying shortly after being moved into a room.
The family also question whether an earlier diagnosis could have changed his treatment options. He first attended hospital with abdominal pain and bloating in June 2024, when he was diagnosed with acute pancreatitis, an inflammation of the pancreas, and discharged.
According to his family, doctors promised a follow-up appointment within two months, but none arrived. When his symptoms worsened, he returned to hospital in November 2024. Doctors found a growth, which they said would be investigated.
A biopsy in January 2025 confirmed pancreatic cancer that had spread to his lungs, liver and bones. Offered chemotherapy or palliative care, he chose to spend his remaining time at home.
Careena, 39, a graphic designer and yoga teacher from Redbridge, London, believes the missed follow-up cost her father the possibility of surgery. That is the family’s assessment; the supplied clinical responses do not establish whether an earlier diagnosis would have made surgery possible.
She said: “Everybody was devastated including him, it was such a shock.
“We were distraught that it had gone that far without us even knowing it could have been cancer.”
She said her father had wanted to remain comfortable at home and that the palliative care team gave her mother a number to call in an emergency or if his pain became too severe. The family understood that staff would attend to give injections to relieve his pain and distress.
On 16 March, however, he collapsed in the bathroom, unable to stand and passing blood in his stool, according to Careena. She says her mother called the team immediately, but staff suggested the bleeding was probably haemorrhoids and refused to send anyone.
Her younger brother pleaded for help, she said, but the family were directed to call 111. As her father screamed for assistance and asked someone to cut off his legs because of the pain, they called 999.
Careena alleges that the first paramedic shouted at him to calm down. Two more arrived and moved him from the bathroom to the bedroom, but she says pain relief was initially withheld because paramedics needed a medication chart from the palliative care team.
She also says they initially refused to take him to hospital, eventually deciding to do so because of the wait for palliative care staff. She followed the ambulance, which travelled without emergency lights.
Her brother Ravi Gharu, 36, accompanied their father in the ambulance. He described him striking its side with his hand and screaming in pain. Careena said morphine was administered during the journey, but her father remained in agony on arrival.
At hospital, she says, he waited in a corridor for at least 20 minutes while she and Ravi sought help. Staff told them he had to be registered by the paramedic before he could be seen, she said.
Careena alleges that when her father pointed to his chest and said he could not breathe, a paramedic dismissed his distress because he could see him breathing.
After he was moved into a room, a paramedic recorded his blood pressure as 44 over 29, she said. She recalled that the paramedic questioned the reading, before her father again said he could not breathe and died. Doctors and nurses then attempted to resuscitate him.
Careena said: “I just can’t believe his last hours were that awful. There were so many mistakes made.”
She formally complained to the ambulance service and palliative care team. Both investigated and produced reports, but she says their responses left her disappointed and appeared to shift responsibility between the services.
She disputes the ambulance service’s explanation for not using emergency lights. Its report said the first paramedic was immediately concerned by blood on her father’s legs and the possibility of a catastrophic haemorrhage or serious injury requiring urgent treatment. It also stated that emergency lights were not used because “the catastrophic internal bleed occurred after arrival at the hospital.”
Careena argues that the blood already visible on his legs contradicts that explanation.
Dr Fenella Wrigley, chief medical officer at London Ambulance Service, offered condolences and said a detailed clinical review had involved senior and specialist end-of-life care clinicians.
She said: “We recognise that aspects of the care and communication experienced by Mr Gharu and his family fell short of what they should expect from us, and we apologise sincerely for this.”
The clinicians involved had reflected on the family’s experience and met the service’s End-of-Life Care team as part of the learning from the complaint, she added.
North East London NHS Foundation Trust, which was responsible for the palliative care team, offered condolences and said it was sorry for the concerns raised. Following a review, it had introduced additional staff training, improved explanations of its community services and established an on-call triage service, with trained nurses able to attend more quickly when urgent care and medication were needed at home.
Barts Health NHS Trust also offered condolences, but defended the hospital care. A spokesperson said: “Having reviewed the clinical notes, we believe Mr Gharu was treated appropriately given the seriousness of his medical condition.”