London Daily← Latest news
Public ·

Cat rescue defends euthanasia decision after staff face online abuse

Yorkshire Cat Rescue says months of veterinary and behavioural support failed to make Tommy safe to rehome; critics accused staff of killing a healthy animal.

A Yorkshire cat rescue charity says its staff faced online abuse and calls to damage its reviews after it put down a cat whose aggressive behaviour had persisted despite months of specialist help.

Lynn Nicholls, 46, chief executive of Yorkshire Cat Rescue, said the decision to euthanise Tommy was the first the charity had made because of behavioural problems. Staff concluded, after consulting specialists, that there was no safe way to rehome him.

Critics accused the charity of “murdering a healthy cat”. Ms Nicholls said she accepted that people might disagree with the decision, but objected to the abuse directed at her team.

“It was the worst experience we’ve had with something happening online,” she said. “It was honestly just disgraceful.”

Tommy had been fed by local people before arriving at the charity in Keighley, West Yorkshire. Staff initially thought he could settle in a home where he had space of his own.

His adopter, however, contacted the rescue in distress after he attacked her without warning. Staff brought him back and spent several months assessing his behaviour, consulting a behaviourist and vets, looking for triggers and trying medication on veterinary advice.

An initial improvement did not last. His progress stalled and his behaviour deteriorated.

Staff considered placing Tommy on a farm or at stables, but ruled that out because, they said, he sought out people before unexpectedly attacking them. Following further discussions with specialists, they decided that euthanasia was the kindest option.

“It’s the most heartbreaking thing, it’s the hardest part of what we do,” Ms Nicholls said.

“This was a massive blow for the whole team, simply because they tried so hard – it’s not particularly what they wanted to do.”

Ms Nicholls said the charity shared news of Tommy’s death as part of its practice of celebrating the lives of animals in its care. The post prompted accusations that staff had killed a healthy cat, alongside false claims that he was feral.

She said 20 comments accused the rescue of murdering a healthy animal. Rejecting that description of Tommy’s health, she pointed to the months spent working with a behaviourist and said people had posted false accounts of what had happened.

“I haven’t got an issue with people not necessarily agreeing with us,” she said. “But what I’ve got an issue with is the online bullying that’s taken place.”

One night, she spent between 1am and 3am blocking abusive users. She said one person urged others to leave hostile Google reviews, which Google subsequently deleted. Other critics called on people to stop supporting the charity.

Ms Nicholls held one-to-one calls with distressed colleagues. “A lot of the team were distraught,” she said.

She warned that a similar backlash could threaten smaller rescues, discouraging people from using them. Yorkshire Cat Rescue had 55,000 followers, she said, and had spent 34 years reaching the point where it could afford to pay some workers.

Ms Nicholls, who took over in 2022, described this as the rescue’s toughest year, with nearly 100 cats arriving each month. Rising costs were making it harder for owners to afford their cats’ care and treatment, she said.

Supporters and other rescues responded with encouraging messages, calls and emails. Despite the abuse, Ms Nicholls said the charity would remain open about its decisions.

“We’re not going to start hiding things we do in case there’s a backlash.”