Veteran challenges police findings after arrest leaves him with broken leg
Joe Mitchell says he intervened after seeing a man hit a woman; police accept causing his injury but say the force used was proportionate
An army veteran left unable to work after his leg broke during an arrest in Cambridge has challenged an investigation’s finding that police used proportionate force.
Joe Mitchell, 37, says an officer tackled him after he intervened when he saw a man hit a woman. Cambridgeshire Police said the officer tripped and fell on him, causing the injury, but an investigation found the arrest lawful and the force proportionate to the circumstances.
Mitchell, an engineer from near Spalding in Lincolnshire, spent five days at Addenbrooke’s Hospital and underwent a seven-hour operation to repair his tibia. Surgeons fitted a metal rod running from his kneecap to his ankle.
He had been celebrating a friend’s 50th birthday on 28 June, in an incident the force dated to 2026. He described a “fantastic” evening, during which he had bought food for a homeless person, and said he had consumed only a few drinks.
At about 1.30am, he said, he saw a man arguing with a woman and hitting her as he walked along the road.
Mitchell said: “I said to him ‘Don’t talk to her like that’.
“He squared up to me and my best mate which was when I pushed him away.
“Within seconds, the police had rugby tackled me to the floor. The investigation said it appeared the officer tripped.”
He said he felt his leg break immediately, but believed the officer initially did not accept that he was injured. He was cautioned and handcuffed, and officers tried to stand him up, he said. According to Mitchell, he was de-arrested only after an ambulance arrived and confirmed the fracture.
“My main concern at that time was that I didn’t want that girl to get hurt,” he said.
Mitchell said he told the officer that the other man had attacked the woman, and that the officer apologised when the injury became apparent. He disputes being treated as the aggressor, saying the police report recorded that the other man had his hands raised in a boxing stance but did not regard that as aggressive.
Mitchell and his wife, Hayley, 39, complained and took legal action. The investigation found that the officer perceived ongoing violence requiring intervention and had an “honest and objectively reasonable suspicion” that Mitchell had committed assault.
Mitchell also said the officer’s body-worn camera was not switched on until he was already on the ground.
He remains on crutches and says he has a limp, his foot is at an angle and he cannot put weight on the leg. Unable to return to engineering work, he is fundraising for living costs, bills and his recovery.
“The other lad was sent home in a taxi while I’ve been left with a broken leg and months of pain,” he said.
Mitchell said the bone was healing as expected but could take up to a year to heal completely. He said bolts securing the rod were touching a nerve in his ankle. Another X-ray was due in three months; if the problem persisted, a screw might need to be removed to prevent numbness and damage. If that failed, he said, surgeons might have to break the leg again and replace the rod.
He served with the 2nd Battalion Royal Anglian Regiment from 2008 to 2012, including service in Jordan, Iraq, Afghanistan, Kenya, Germany and Cyprus. Although he suffered three fractured vertebrae during his military service, he said this was his first complete fracture.
Hayley questioned why her husband had been de-arrested if his conduct justified the force used. She said they had been told they had no claim and could not afford further solicitors’ fees, while she had been working all hours to cover their housing costs.
She criticised the treatment of veterans, particularly with Remembrance Day approaching, and said Mitchell had previously collected for the Royal British Legion. Mitchell said he had received no support from the council or government, despite always trying to help others.
Cambridgeshire Police said it received his complaint in June and referred it to the Independent Office for Police Conduct under mandatory referral criteria. It was returned to the force for local investigation.
A spokesperson said: “The Professional Standards Department investigation found that whilst the injury was caused by police, it was deemed that the force used was proportionate to the circumstances surrounding the situation and the arrest.”