London Daily← Latest news
Public ·

Arctic ice links widespread arsenic pollution to one US copper operation

Researchers estimate that emissions from Montana’s Anaconda operation exposed 50.5 million Americans to potentially harmful arsenic levels

Pollution from a single Montana copper operation reached the Arctic and may have exposed more than half of Americans to arsenic levels associated with serious health risks, according to a study of ice cores.

Researchers traced a roughly 15-fold rise in toxic metals recorded in Arctic ice between about 1886 and 1918 to the Anaconda Copper Mine complex near Butte, then one of the world’s largest copper producers. Their findings suggest that introducing pollution controls a decade earlier could have prevented tens of thousands of tons of arsenic and lead emissions.

The Desert Research Institute (DRI) team analysed 10 ice cores from Greenland, the Russian Arctic and northern Canada. These frozen records preserve particles carried by winds and deposited by storms, allowing scientists to reconstruct atmospheric pollution during the second Industrial Revolution.

Combining the measurements with atmospheric modelling and the operation’s historical records, the researchers estimated annual emissions of 11,000 tons of arsenic and 4,400 tons of lead during its two to three decades of peak production.

The study, published in Nature Sustainability, estimates potential health impacts rather than documenting individual illnesses. Using American and Canadian census figures from 1910 and 1911 alongside their models, the researchers calculated that about 50.5 million Americans and 600,000 Canadians lived in areas exposed to arsenic pollution at levels associated with increased risks of lung cancer and other serious conditions. That represented about 55% of Americans and 11% of Canadians.

People closest to the operation, in Montana and parts of Wyoming and Idaho, were exposed for nearly 30 years to arsenic levels that the researchers said met or exceeded the World Health Organisation’s current recommended maximum for chronic exposure. Recent arsenic pollution levels in the United States and Europe are between 12 and 60 times lower.

The team also estimated that 1.4 million Americans and Canadians, including all residents of Montana and Wyoming, experienced elevated lead pollution potentially linked to cognitive decline equivalent to a reduction of 2.6 IQ points.

Study co-author Dr Joe McConnell, of the DRI, said: “It’s pretty wild to think that a single, albeit massive source of pollution could have affected effectively the entire North American continent and western Greenland more than 4,000 kilometres or 2,500 miles away.”

Identifying the source required records from across the Arctic. Arsenic and lead generally remain airborne for only days before being deposited, so differences between the ice cores helped the team establish how pollution spread over time and distance. Atmospheric modelling pointed to northern North America.

Anaconda’s historical records were an almost perfect match for the arsenic pollution recorded in the ice, while lead isotope measurements were also consistent with the operation being the principal source.

Dr McConnell said: “Everything points to Anaconda – an infamous source of arsenic pollution in this country.”

He explained that copper smelters are among the largest sources of arsenic pollution. Demand for copper and other metals rose sharply during the rapid electrification of the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

A central Greenland ice core showed arsenic rising slowly between 1850 and 1887, then rapidly until 1895. Levels peaked at about 15 times their pre-industrial level around the start of the First World War in 1914.

They fell sharply after the war until 1920, recovered slightly, then declined again during the worst of the Great Depression between 1932 and 1934. Although concentrations subsequently rose, they remained well below the wartime peak through 2020.

The researchers believe the significant fall after 1919 was probably linked to the installation of electrostatic precipitators at the Anaconda Smelter. The ice record indicates that heavy-metal emissions fell by about 65%.

Their calculations suggest that installing those controls 10 years earlier would have prevented an additional 60,000 tons of arsenic and 24,000 tons of lead pollution across much of North America.

Dr McConnell said: “The parents and grandparents of many Americans alive today were exposed to this heavy metal pollution, so the health impacts are quite recent and close to home.” He expressed hope that the data would support further work on the health consequences.