The Law Commission will examine whether sexual consent in England and Wales should require agreement explicitly communicated through words or actions, potentially changing how defendants can argue they reasonably believed someone consented.
The review will consider affirmative consent models in Canada and New South Wales. These do not require a spoken ‘yes’ alone: agreement can also be communicated through conduct. The commission describes the existing law as ‘unsettled, incoherent and unpredictable’.
Under current legislation, consent means agreeing by choice, with the freedom and capacity to choose. A defendant can nevertheless be acquitted if a jury finds they reasonably believed the other person consented, considering all the circumstances, including steps taken to establish consent.
The distinction under examination concerns what must underpin that belief. Canada bars reliance on mistaken belief unless agreement was affirmatively expressed through words or conduct. Its supreme court ruled in 2019 that consent must be affirmatively communicated for every sexual act. In New South Wales, rules introduced on 1 June 2022 require someone to say or do something communicating consent; silence, passivity and lack of resistance do not suffice.
Joanne Young called this week for an urgent review after being raped and sexually assaulted by strangers while drugged by her husband, Philip Young. He was convicted of drugging and raping her and falsely claimed she had agreed to sexual contact with men he recruited to abuse her.
Four men told the court they believed they had both spouses’ consent after he said she was pretending to be asleep. Mrs Young said: “At no point did anyone ask me for my consent.”
Hetti Barkworth-Nanton, chairman of domestic abuse charity Refuge, wants the review to challenge rape myths and examine how courts understand and test consent. She said: “Women’s voices matter, and nobody else can consent on their behalf.”
Professor Clare McGlynn, an expert on sexual violence, argues that resources should instead go towards enforcing existing laws, which she says already cover these situations when properly understood. She also argues that tackling accessible rape pornography, including sleep content, would achieve more than introducing affirmative consent legislation.
Separate calls from MPs and campaigners seek a staggered age of consent for 16- and 17-year-olds to prevent exploitation by adults.
The commission last examined consent in the 1990s, before the Sexual Offences Act 2003 established the current rules. Reform could bring the largest overhaul in two decades, but no change has been settled: proposals will undergo public consultation before final recommendations reach the government.









Join the conversation