London Daily

Focus on the big picture.

German court says yes to recovery fund — but maybe not to much else

German court says yes to recovery fund — but maybe not to much else

Constitutional court cleared the way for the EU to issue joint debt to finance its recovery fund , but it did not give a ringing endorsement.
Just when it looked like the tide might be turning in favor of the EU pooling its resources to stave off crises or fund one-off super-projects, it looks like Germany might be putting the brakes on again.

While the country's constitutional court on Tuesday cleared the way for the bloc to issue joint debt to finance its €750 billion recovery fund — the unprecedented scheme governments in the EU established as they struggled with the costs of the pandemic in 2020 — it was far from a ringing endorsement for anything similar any time soon.

That common debt issuance, the first of its kind in the EU, was legitimate, the court ruled, because it was temporary, exceptional, linked to a specific purpose and not larger than the overall EU budget. That will draw sighs of relief from Brussels and other countries which had staked much political capital on the ambitious package.

But there was a big caveat. "It would be manifestly impermissible for the European Union to borrow on capital markets to provide general financing for its budget," the court said.

As the EU battles rising inflation and a sluggish economy and is faced with questions over how to help rebuild Ukraine, the question of how much governments should spend to boost growth has come under renewed focus.

The recovery fund, known as NextGenerationEU and agreed in July 2020 at the same time as the bloc's €1 trillion seven-year budget, was seen then as a one-off. But its success has led to calls for other projects along similar lines, such as to help fund Kyiv's reconstruction efforts.

That looks to be unlikely after the German court's ruling, analysts said.

"This is not a positive sign for future fiscal integration," said Thu Nguyen, of the Jacques Delors Centre. "The court seems extremely skeptical, essentially arguing all along that the program is legally very problematic, only to then conclude that it will not block it."

The recovery fund allows the European Commission to raise money on capital markets to help finance jointly agreed reforms and investment plans of member countries, partly as grants and partly as loans.

It was seen as breaking a long-standing EU taboo about the pooling of debt. But it raised fears, particularly in richer countries like Germany, that they would be liable for the bill if other governments defaulted.

It's this that alarmed judges in Germany.

"The court raised serious doubts about whether the joint issuance to finance the fund is in line with the treaty of the functioning of the EU," said Holger Schmieding, chief economist at Berenberg Bank. "The German court — once again — emphasized German limits for EU fiscal integration.”

The ruling leaves "the question open" of whether the court would approve the participation in further joint EU debt issuance in the future, he added.

Plaintiffs had sought to stop the joint debt issuance, arguing that it was illegal and contrary to the wording of Article 311 of the Treaty of the Functioning of the European Union to finance expenditures of the bloc's budget by issuing debt.

They also said the program implied incalculable liability risks for Germany's federal budget, meaning that the government should never have agreed to the country's participation.

The German government had approved the scheme. The court in Karlsruhe ruled that it did not present an “obvious infringement” on rules governing European integration. “Also, it does not impair the overall budgetary responsibility of the German Bundestag.”

The decision is "far from a blank cheque" for future initiatives, said International Monetary Fund legal counsel Sebastian Grund.

There might still be some wriggle room, however, with analysts pointing out that at one time the German government's approval of the recovery fund in the first place would have been unthinkable.

The decision opens the door to some joint debt issuance on other tailored spending projects, according to Friedrich Heinemann, of the ZEW economic research group.

"With this tailwind from Karlsruhe, the pressure from Brussels on the federal government will now increase to clear the way for debt financing of new EU programs, he said.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
British police appear unprepared to deal with usual suspects
Russia's Ballistic Blitz on Kyiv Sends Shockwaves Through Global Stability
Multiple Tragedies and Tensions Mark Global Events: A Closer Look
Elon Musk's AfD Endorsement Ignites Controversy from neo-Nazis who accuse the AfD of being what they themselves are
Ukraine Claims Unprecedented Russian Losses: The Truth Behind Wartime Statistics
Federal Reserve Chair Powell: "We are prohibited from owning Bitcoin and are not seeking any changes to that law."
A Democratic congresswoman with blue and black hair is having a meltdown over "President Musk."
A sizable group of unauthorized migrants is traveling through Mexico with the aim of reaching the USA before Trump assumes office.
Beatles Reunion Electrifies London: Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr Ignite O2 Arena with Surprise Performance
Starmer's Envoy Engages Trump Team as UK Seeks Strategic U.S. Partnership
Britain's Retail Rebound Falters as Black Friday Splurge Dissipates
Bank of Japan's Bold Reckoning: A Decade of Unconventional Policy Under Scrutiny
Republican Discord Threatens Government Shutdown Amid Holiday Season
French Retiree Dominique Pellico Convicted for Recruiting 72 Men to Assault Wife Over a Decade
Putin Defends War Strategy as Global Tensions Rise
Putin Claims Progress as Tensions Rise: Conflict in Ukraine Intensifies
Putin's Paradox: Claiming Strength Amidst Sanctions and Isolation
Water as a Weapon: The Contentious Struggle for Survival in Gaza
Syria's Future: A Fight for Democracy or Another Cycle of Oppression?
UK Considers Sending Troops to Ukraine: A Strategic Move or Intensifying The Proxy War?
Renewed ISIS Threat Puts Syria’s Cultural Heritage in Peril
Escalation in Moscow: High-Profile Assassination and International Tensions Intensify
North Korean Troops in Ukraine: A New Cold War Frontier?
Ukraine's Bold Move: High-Stakes Assassination of Russian General in Moscow
Dubai's Technological Leap: Brain Chips and AI Board Members by 2025
Tragedy Strikes Wisconsin School as Shooting Claims Lives of Teacher and Student
UK's Calculated Gamble: Balancing Defense Aid to Ukraine and Domestic Demands
UK Intensifies Stranglehold on Russian Oil, but Does It Dampen Putin’s Resolve?
British Voter Endorsement of Reeves's Bold Tax Strategy
Nicola Sturgeon Warns of 'Toxic' Discourse: The Perils of Polarisation in Modern Politics
Levelling Down: How the Conservatives Underspent on Regional Revitalization
Alleged Chinese Espionage: The Entangled Web Beyond Prince Andrew
Starmer Navigates Diplomatic Tightrope Amid Chinese Espionage Revelations Involving Prince Andrew
Balancing Democracy and Disorder: The Trial of a Milkshake Incident
Royal Mail Enters New Chapter Under Czech Ownership
UK Companies Slash Jobs Amid Economic Strain
Kemi Badenoch Rekindles Flat Tax Debate Amid Inheritance Tax Uproar
Rewiring Whitehall: New Cabinet Secretary's Mandate for Change
Legal Battle Revives: Lucy Letby Seeks Fresh Appeal as Expert Evidence Faces Scrutiny
Accusations Fly as UK-China Relations Spark Tension Within British Politics
The Delicate Dance of Devolution: As English Council Elections Face Delays
The Alleged Chinese Spy at the Heart of British Royal Circles: Yang Tengbo Unmasked
Prince Andrew Withdraws from Royal Christmas Amidst Chinese Espionage Scandal
EU Takes Legal Action Against UK Over Allegedly Neglected Rights of EU Citizens
Disaster Strikes: Oil Spill in the Black Sea and Cyclone Devastation in Mayotte
Oil Tanker Disaster in the Kerch Strait: A Confluence of Environmental Catastrophe and Geopolitical Tensions
Olaf Scholz’s Gamble: The Collapse of Germany’s Coalition Government and the Path to Early Elections
Keir Starmer's 'Sycophantic' Tone: Tensions Rise Over UK-China Relations
Trump Recognizes Partial Advances in Ceasefire Attempts in Ukraine Conflict
UK Navigates Complex Global and Domestic Challenges Amid Security, Environmental, and Health Concerns
×