London Daily

Focus on the big picture.

German court says yes to recovery fund — but maybe not to much else

German court says yes to recovery fund — but maybe not to much else

Constitutional court cleared the way for the EU to issue joint debt to finance its recovery fund , but it did not give a ringing endorsement.
Just when it looked like the tide might be turning in favor of the EU pooling its resources to stave off crises or fund one-off super-projects, it looks like Germany might be putting the brakes on again.

While the country's constitutional court on Tuesday cleared the way for the bloc to issue joint debt to finance its €750 billion recovery fund — the unprecedented scheme governments in the EU established as they struggled with the costs of the pandemic in 2020 — it was far from a ringing endorsement for anything similar any time soon.

That common debt issuance, the first of its kind in the EU, was legitimate, the court ruled, because it was temporary, exceptional, linked to a specific purpose and not larger than the overall EU budget. That will draw sighs of relief from Brussels and other countries which had staked much political capital on the ambitious package.

But there was a big caveat. "It would be manifestly impermissible for the European Union to borrow on capital markets to provide general financing for its budget," the court said.

As the EU battles rising inflation and a sluggish economy and is faced with questions over how to help rebuild Ukraine, the question of how much governments should spend to boost growth has come under renewed focus.

The recovery fund, known as NextGenerationEU and agreed in July 2020 at the same time as the bloc's €1 trillion seven-year budget, was seen then as a one-off. But its success has led to calls for other projects along similar lines, such as to help fund Kyiv's reconstruction efforts.

That looks to be unlikely after the German court's ruling, analysts said.

"This is not a positive sign for future fiscal integration," said Thu Nguyen, of the Jacques Delors Centre. "The court seems extremely skeptical, essentially arguing all along that the program is legally very problematic, only to then conclude that it will not block it."

The recovery fund allows the European Commission to raise money on capital markets to help finance jointly agreed reforms and investment plans of member countries, partly as grants and partly as loans.

It was seen as breaking a long-standing EU taboo about the pooling of debt. But it raised fears, particularly in richer countries like Germany, that they would be liable for the bill if other governments defaulted.

It's this that alarmed judges in Germany.

"The court raised serious doubts about whether the joint issuance to finance the fund is in line with the treaty of the functioning of the EU," said Holger Schmieding, chief economist at Berenberg Bank. "The German court — once again — emphasized German limits for EU fiscal integration.”

The ruling leaves "the question open" of whether the court would approve the participation in further joint EU debt issuance in the future, he added.

Plaintiffs had sought to stop the joint debt issuance, arguing that it was illegal and contrary to the wording of Article 311 of the Treaty of the Functioning of the European Union to finance expenditures of the bloc's budget by issuing debt.

They also said the program implied incalculable liability risks for Germany's federal budget, meaning that the government should never have agreed to the country's participation.

The German government had approved the scheme. The court in Karlsruhe ruled that it did not present an “obvious infringement” on rules governing European integration. “Also, it does not impair the overall budgetary responsibility of the German Bundestag.”

The decision is "far from a blank cheque" for future initiatives, said International Monetary Fund legal counsel Sebastian Grund.

There might still be some wriggle room, however, with analysts pointing out that at one time the German government's approval of the recovery fund in the first place would have been unthinkable.

The decision opens the door to some joint debt issuance on other tailored spending projects, according to Friedrich Heinemann, of the ZEW economic research group.

"With this tailwind from Karlsruhe, the pressure from Brussels on the federal government will now increase to clear the way for debt financing of new EU programs, he said.
Newsletter

Related Articles

London Daily
0:00
0:00
Close
UK Maintains Non-negotiable Stance on Falklands and Gibraltar
Controversy Surrounds A75 Road Closures and 96-Mile Diversion
Crunch Time in Conservative Leadership Race
Keir Starmer's Challenges in the Wake of Sue Gray's Departure
Coroner Urges UK Government to Improve Severe ME Care
Starmer Calls for De-escalation in Middle East Amid Heightened Tensions
Chancellor Reeves Decides Against Pension Tax Hike
UK Advocates Urge Tobacco Windfall Tax and Permanent Levy
Starmer's Chief of Staff Plans Major Overhaul at Downing Street
Key Labour Thinktank Advocates New Powers for Mayors
Rachel Reeves Considers New Fiscal Rules for Infrastructure Spending
Great Britain Faces Lowest Winter Blackout Risk in Four Years
The Impact of Online Culture on Young Women: Survey Insights
Hypersonic Jet to Revolutionize Air Travel
Russian Medic Arrested for Alleged Satanism and Promoting LGBTQ Rights
UK: Chagos Islands Deal Was About Securing US Military Base
RT has converted key archive speeches delivered by Putin into spoken English using the help of AI
Walmart is now selling a new book titled The Achievements of Kamala Harris—and all the pages are blank.
Bill Gates: "6% of global emissions are cows... You can either fix the cows to stop them farting, or you can make beef without the cow."
Facilitated Communication: Miracle Tool or Manipulative Method?
The Allure of Browsing Online Property Portals: A Modern Obsession
Suspected Acid Attacker in London Bailed Amid Investigation
Tragic Channel Crossing: Four Migrants Killed
Labour Cabinet Ministers' Stances on Assisted Dying
The Influence of Tory Members on Party Leadership
UK Plans Major Overhaul of Employment Rights
UK Food Industry Lobbying Delays £1.7 Billion Plastic Packaging Tax
New UK Tipping Law Sparks Confusion Among Restaurant Staff
Debate Heats Up Over Assisted Dying Legislation in the UK
New Personalized Cancer Therapies Undergo Extensive Clinical Study
UAE Energy Minister: OPEC+ Doing a 'Noble' Job in Balancing Oil Market
Call for Wealth Tax Hikes to Curb Reform UK's Rise
Labour MP Supports Chancellor's Rejection of Wealth Tax
Debate Intensifies Over VAT Introduction for UK Private Schools
Israel Plans Retaliation Against Iran Amid Rising Regional Tensions
Norwegian Police Conclude 'Spy Whale' Hvaldimir's Death Due to Infection
Dominica Sells Citizenship to Boost Climate Resilience
Greta Thunberg Detained in Brussels During Protest Against Fossil Fuel Subsidies
UK Returns Chagos Islands to Mauritius After Decades-Long Dispute
UK Reaffirms Commitment to Overseas Territories Amid Falkland Islands Dispute
France's Silent March Supports Gisèle Pelicot: A Shocking Case
Robert Jenrick's Leadership Prospects: Challenges from the Right
Declining Interest in Grammar Schools Amid VAT Concerns
Emirates Bans Pagers and Walkie-Talkies on All Flights
Malaysian Father Burns Son's Motorbike to Prevent Racing Accidents
Donald Trump Urges Israel to Hit Iran's Nuclear Facilities First
Private Schools Face Enrollment Decline Due to Impending VAT on Fees
Wetherspoon’s CEO Criticizes Smaller Beer Glass Proposal and Licensing Hour Reduction
Starmer Defends UK Chagos Islands Decision Amidst Tory Criticism
Naomi Campbell Banned from Charity Work After Fashion for Relief Mismanagement
×