Quote of the day
Be a philosopher; but, amidst all your philosophy, be still a man.
From Section I of An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding, first published in London in 1748 as Philosophical Essays concerning Human Understanding. The advice is voiced by personified Nature; the sentence’s precise date and place of composition are not established.
1 min read
Nature’s advice
Hume’s sentence belongs to the opening section of a philosophical work, not to a recorded speech or an especially improving dinner-table conversation. Published in London in 1748, the book acquired its familiar title, An Enquiry concerning Human Understanding, in 1758. Its opening considers different ways of pursuing philosophy and their place in human life.
The immediate speaker is Nature, whom Hume personifies as offering counsel to humanity. This is a rhetorical device, not a separate historical speaker. Nature recommends a mixed life: intellectual enquiry should have its share, alongside sociability, practical occupation and recreation. None should be permitted to swallow the rest.
Balance is not surrender
Read in isolation, the maxim might sound like permission to abandon difficult thinking. The surrounding argument makes that interpretation untenable. Hume promptly defends abstract reasoning against indiscriminate dismissal: careful investigation supplies the precision that more accessible writing about conduct and character requires.
His comparison is between the anatomist and the painter. Detailed knowledge of what lies beneath the surface can improve what is presented to the eye. Likewise, rigorous philosophy can strengthen lucid moral reflection. The injunction is therefore to keep thought in proportion, not to dispense with its more demanding forms.
A Scottish mind, a European legacy
David Hume, born in Edinburgh in 1711, was a Scottish philosopher, essayist and historian, and a principal figure of the Scottish Enlightenment. His major works include A Treatise of Human Nature, the two Enquiries and the six-volume History of England. His essays and histories enjoyed greater appreciation during his lifetime than his philosophy.
His investigation of human nature placed experience and observation at its centre, examining belief, causation, morality and religion. His influence reached his friend Adam Smith and the German philosopher Immanuel Kant. Hume’s place in Britain’s cultural inheritance is thus distinctly Scottish and thoroughly European: an intellectual legacy that crossed both disciplines and borders.