London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Saturday, Oct 24, 2026

Britain has a decision to make: the rule of Boris Johnson – or the rule of law?

Britain has a decision to make: the rule of Boris Johnson – or the rule of law?

For 800 years, traditions and statute have protected citizens from tyranny. This PM will trash it all
Don’t succumb to Johnson derangement syndrome, they tell us. Stay calm. Keep a sense of proportion. Don’t get carried away. As a matter of self-care, that might be good advice for those at risk of bursting a blood vessel in their rage at this government and its leader. But learning to shrug off Boris Johnson’s conduct carries risks of its own. It can mean missing, or underreacting to, acts that merit furious opposition – such as when, before our very eyes, the prime minister destroys the principle that sits at the very foundation of a free society, a principle first codified in this country eight centuries ago and without which a life free of fear is impossible. I’m talking about the rule of law.

It’s so basic, we take it for granted. It’s the notion, spelt out in Magna Carta in 1215, that even those in power do not enjoy unlimited or unfettered authority, but are constrained by rules; that even the sovereign – the state – is subject to the law of the land. Only then can citizens feel relatively safe from the threat of arbitrary power, safe from a king – or prime minister – doing whatever the hell he likes.

After 1945, having witnessed the murderous horrors of totalitarianism and seen where unchecked state power could lead, Britain and the US moved to expand the Magna Carta principle. From now on, states would be subject to the constraint not only of their own domestic law, but international law too. The world after Hitler would be a rules-based order.

But look at things now. “We’re fucking breaking international law like it’s one of our five a day,” one government official tells Politico. The frequency is indeed striking. On Monday the foreign secretary, Liz Truss, presented a bill to “fix” the Northern Ireland protocol, “disapplying” – ignoring – those post-Brexit trade rules the government now finds inconvenient.

Put aside the crude politics of it: ramping up yet another battle with Brussels because that was the playbook Johnson won with, and he knows no other. Put aside the fact that most citizens in Northern Ireland not only voted against Brexit but voted for parties that support the protocol and don’t want to see it scrapped. Put aside the stinking hypocrisy of a government complaining about the terms of an agreement it itself negotiated, praised and pushed through parliament just two years ago.

Focus instead on what is actually happening here. The UK government is breaking a binding international legal agreement, and admitting as much in the text of its bill, which invokes the “doctrine of necessity” in seeking to justify its violation of its obligations (a doctrine that doesn’t, in fact, apply when the “necessity” arises only because of policy decisions the government itself took). No wonder there is alarm in Washington as well as in EU capitals: a nation that 80 years ago was leading the way in establishing a rules-based order is now apparently bent on destroying it. The New Yorker calls Britain a “rogue nation”.

That was the clear message that came the day after the Northern Ireland “fix”, when in an 11th-hour ruling the European court of human rights blocked the transfer of a handful of asylum seekers from Britain to Rwanda. Again, ignore the gross culture war motivation behind this policy, the naked desire to rally the 2016 anti-immigration base, to enjoy again the thrill of bashing do-gooding lawyers and “European judges” (even though the ECHR has nothing to do with the EU). Put aside the cruelty of dumping desperate people in a faraway land, the callousness of trying to outsource Britain’s moral duty – because providing safe harbour to refugees is a moral duty – to an authoritarian state.

Focus instead on the fact that this move was found to be a violation of a convention on human rights drafted in part by David Maxwell Fyfe, a Conservative politician, member of Winston Churchill’s cabinet and onetime prosecutor of Nazi war criminals at Nuremberg. And note Johnson’s response when asked if Britain should withdraw from the ECHR it had helped create, given the obstacles the convention was placing in the way of the Rwanda policy: “Will it be necessary to change some laws to help us as we go along? It may very well be.”

The next day, Wednesday, Christopher Geidt resigned as the PM’s ethics adviser, apparently, if not wholly credibly, over a decision on trade policy: tellingly, the move he was asked to approve would have clashed with Britain’s obligations under WTO rules. The pattern is plain enough. Without much publicity, the government has, for example, entirely ignored rulings in 2019 and 2021 by the international court of justice and the international tribunal for the law of the sea outlawing Britain’s continued occupation of the Chagos islands in the Indian Ocean. As Philippe Sands QC, who has acted in the case, told me: “Britain’s reputation is uniquely built on the rule of law – and this government is trashing it.”

Of course, the international violations mirror the domestic ones. Whatever the precise nature of the last straw, Geidt’s back was broken by the serial rule-breaking of the man he served. Every single minute that he has been prime minister, Johnson has been under investigation, culminating in the fine he received for breaking the law by partying during lockdown – and his refusal to resign once he had. But none of that should have come as a surprise. Johnson demonstrated his contempt for the law within weeks of taking office by proroguing parliament, seeking to bypass and silence the nation’s elected representatives. The supreme court thwarted him, but his attitude was clear. “We used to be a country where the rule of law really mattered,” says the chair of the Commons standards committee, Chris Bryant. “All of that is thrown away.”

Gideon Rachman’s new book, The Age of the Strongman, includes Johnson alongside the likes of Donald Trump, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and Viktor Orbán – and this, despite the obvious differences, is one of the chief reasons why. What these men have in common is disdain for any constraint on their own power. If the law enables them to have their way, then it is legitimate. If it does not, it can be broken or ignored. Those who insist on it – lawyers and judges, for example – are demonised as politically motivated partisans, meddling, out-of-touch elitists, “enemies of the people”.

Yet the rule of law is anything but the preserve of the elite. It is the last, most precious protection of the weak against the whims of the strong. It is what stands between us and tyranny. Our prime minister poses a grave threat to it – and it’s not deranged to say so.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Northern Ireland Executive Ministers Reach Consensus on Shared Economic Development Priorities to Stimulate Regional Growth in Belfast
Department for Business and Trade Finalizes Conditional Support Package for Advanced Semiconductor Fabrication Facilities in Newport
Welsh Government Unveils Regional Industrial Development Strategy to Attract Green Energy Investment to South Wales Manufacturing Hubs
Foreign Secretary David Lammy Concludes Diplomatic Mission to European Capital Cities to Strengthen Post-Brexit Defense Cooperation
Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Implements Stricter Regulatory Compliance Standards for Water Utilities Across England
Office for National Statistics Reports Moderate Wage Growth Stabilization and Resilient Employment Figures Across the United Kingdom
Scottish Government and Trade Union Representatives Reach Tentative Pay Agreement for Public Sector Transport Workers in Edinburgh
National Health Service England Announces Emergency Capital Funding Allocation to Reduce Winter Emergency Department Bottlenecks
Bank of England Monetary Policy Committee Signals Cautious Approach to Interest Rate Reductions Amid Persistent Inflation Pressures
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Treasury Officials Finalize Urgent Fiscal Adjustments Ahead of Upcoming National Budget
Tour de France Organizers Confirm Historic Grand Depart Featuring Edinburgh and Yorkshire Stages
National Cyber Security Centre Issues Urgent Alerts Following Global Security Vulnerability in Core Programming Software
Independent Energy Analysts Warn Great Britain Faces Highest Winter Power Tariffs in Europe
Major British Defense Contractors Commit to Delivering Forty Thousand New Apprenticeships and Training Placements
New Bradford Railway Station Infrastructure Project Approved to Transform Regional Transit Connectivity Across Northern England
Welsh Infrastructure Stakeholders Press Government for Accelerated Local Sourcing in Military and Uniform Manufacturing
Scottish Council Governance Crisis Triggers High-Court Legal Challenge Over Leadership Ouster Bid
High Street Bakery Chain Greggs Announces Major Factory Closures and Seven Hundred Job Cuts
Automotive Manufacturer Jaguar Land Rover Advances Advanced Defense Technology Partnership with European Allies
Treasury and Bank of England Officials Signal Persistent Concern Over Inflation-Driven Interest Rate Path
International Monetary Fund Upgrades United Kingdom Growth Forecast While Issuing Inflation Warnings
National Health Service Leaders Warn of Severe Capacity Pressures as Early Winter Respiratory Infections Surge
Government Issues Emergency Resilience Guidance Advising All British Citizens to Stockpile Essential Supplies
United Kingdom Private Sector Growth Beats Expectations in October Driven by Resilient Services and Manufacturing
Barclays to Cut Five Thousand Jobs in Major Artificial Intelligence Adoption and Cost-Cutting Overhaul
Piper Tomahawk Aircraft Crash Near Drymen in Stirling Claims Two Lives as Investigators Deploy
North Sea Transition Authority Approves Jackdaw Gas Field Production After Ministerial Authorization
Government Injects One Hundred and Forty Million Pounds to Expand Urgent Care Ahead of Winter Crisis
Department of Health Warns Further Pay Rises Will Derail National Health Service Waiting List Targets
Major Environmental Emergency Declared in South Wales Following Aerospace Kerosene Spill
Tank Barrel Production Returns to Britain as Defence Contractors Accelerate Domestic Rearmament
Government Approves Controversial Jackdaw Gasfield Development in the North Sea
National Health Service Maternity Safety Review Condemned Over Flawed Artificial Intelligence Integration
Dozens of United Kingdom Government Services Taken Offline Amid Critical Software Vulnerability
Barclays Announces Five Thousand Job Cuts Citing Artificial Intelligence Productivity Gains
Treasury Relaxes Post-Financial Crisis Accountability Rules for City of London Executives
United Kingdom Government Issues Unprecedented Guidance Urging Citizens to Stockpile Essential Supplies
United Kingdom Consumer Inflation Accelerates to Eleven-Month High Driven by Transport Costs
United Kingdom Public Sector Net Debt Breaches Three Trillion Pounds Ahead of Autumn Budget
Department for Science, Innovation and Technology Commits Fifty Million Pounds to Establish Regional Artificial Intelligence Innovation Clusters
Ofgem Directs Major Energy Suppliers to Expand Vulnerable Household Support Funds Ahead of Winter Heating Season
Home Office and National Police Chiefs Council Unveil New Intelligence-Led Strategy to Tackle Organised Immigration Crime Networks
First Minister John Swinney Secures Scottish Parliament Approval for Comprehensive Climate and Green Energy Infrastructure Strategy
National Health Service England and Trades Union Congress Finalize Agreement on Emergency Winter Staffing and Pay Frameworks
HM Treasury and Department for Business and Trade Announce Multi-Billion-Pound Sovereign Investment Pact to Spur Regional Advanced Manufacturing
Bank of England Governor Andrew Bailey Signals Potential for Faster Interest Rate Cuts as Domestic Inflation Pressures Ease Below Forecasts
Parliamentary Inquiry Highlights Urgent Need to Address Housing Shortage as Scottish Completions Hit Eleven-Year Low
United Kingdom and Singapore Sign Comprehensive Financial Agreement to Deepen Digital and Sustainable Market Ties
Greggs Announces Plan to Close Four Manufacturing Facilities and Cut Seven Hundred and Forty Jobs
International Monetary Fund Raises United Kingdom Economic Growth Forecast While Warning of Inflationary Pressures
×