A woman who accuses Russell Brand of raping her when she was 16 and he was 30 has called for a staggered age of consent, under which the legality of sexual activity would depend on both partners’ ages.

The proposal would change the significance of reaching the UK’s current age of consent of 16: an older partner’s age could still make sexual activity unlawful. Advocates argue that the existing threshold offers insufficient protection against exploitation by substantially older adults.

The campaign group Close the Consent Gap wants to make it a criminal offence for someone aged 20 or over to have sex with a 16- or 17-year-old where the age difference is at least three years. Its approach would therefore introduce an age-gap restriction rather than raise the age of consent uniformly for everyone.

Louise Haigh, described as the de facto deputy prime minister, said a staggered system deserved ‘proper consideration and scrutiny’. She did not endorse a particular model. Welfare Secretary Pat McFadden said reform was ‘certainly something ministers will talk about’, adding: ‘We probably will consider it but I cannot give you a result of that at the moment.’

International examples show that a staggered system can take different forms. Florida sets the age of consent at 18, reduced to 16 where the other person is under 24. Canada allows 14- and 15-year-olds to consent where the other person is less than five years older; Italy uses a narrower three-year gap.

These distinctions matter in practice. A rule based on an older partner’s maximum age draws a different boundary from one based on the distance between two birthdays. Ministers have not settled either the thresholds or whether to legislate.

The debate is also separate from the government’s commitment to change offence classifications in England and Wales so that sex with anyone under 16 is classed as rape, following Baroness Louise Casey’s grooming gangs review. That concerns offences below the existing consent threshold; the new campaign seeks additional restrictions above it.