London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Friday, Mar 21, 2025

UK: 9-Year-Old Girl Under Investigation for Commenting That Another Girl "Smells Like Fish."

Absurd Cases Emphasize Increasing Trend to Criminalize Speech and Suppress Criticism in Europe; Criticism Directed at Police for Investigating "Non-Crime Hate Incidents," Even in Cases Involving Children
In a stark illustration of the extent to which speech is being criminalized, UK police have investigated a nine-year-old for calling a classmate a “retard.” Similarly, two secondary schoolgirls were recorded for a “hate incident” after telling a peer they smelled “like fish.” Such schoolyard spats, though certainly impolite, are now categorized as “non-crime hate incidents” (NCHIs), highlighting the increasingly absurd measures authorities are taking to regulate speech.

This issue isn't confined to Britain. Across Europe, countries like Germany and France are witnessing similar trends where legitimate criticism, expressions of frustration, and even childish insults are being criminalized, raising serious concerns about free speech and government intrusion.

Children Targeted in Speech Regulation Efforts

Freedom of information requests have shown that children are among the thousands being investigated for NCHIs. These incidents are being documented despite guidelines indicating they should only apply to actions “clearly motivated by intentional hostility” and posing a genuine risk of escalating into significant harm or criminal acts.

Recording incidents like these—mere schoolyard chatter—defies common sense. It diverts police resources and sets a dangerous precedent where innocuous, though inappropriate, comments are treated as legal matters.

A Concerning Trend Across Europe

The UK is not alone in its trend of speech policing. In Germany, citizens have faced raids for sharing memes critical of government officials. In France, protests against corruption and mismanagement have been met with accusations of “hate speech” and severe crackdowns. Across these countries, legitimate expressions of dissent or criticism are increasingly being categorized as criminal or near-criminal behavior.

Critics argue that this isn’t about protecting marginalized groups—it’s about quelling dissent. Governments are using the pretext of combating hate to suppress criticism of their own incompetence, corruption, and failure to tackle genuine problems.

The Real Cost of Criminalizing Speech

The absurdity of policing schoolyard remarks is evident, especially when crime rates in parts of Europe are rising, and law enforcement budgets are stretched thin. Time and resources spent documenting playground disputes or social media posts could be more effectively used to address serious offenses.

Furthermore, this trend undermines democratic principles. Free speech, even when offensive, is crucial for holding governments accountable. Criminalizing words—especially those far from genuine hostility—stifles public debate and discourages dissent.

A Slippery Slope for Free Expression

The broader ramifications of these policies must not be overlooked. Today, a nine-year-old is logged for a careless remark; tomorrow, it could be any citizen expressing legitimate criticism of government policies. Where does it end?

Criticism, even harsh criticism, is vital in a functioning democracy. It ensures transparency, accountability, and the ability to challenge authority. Treating schoolyard comments or political memes as hate incidents undermines these values and paves the way for widespread surveillance and repression.

The Need for Change

The rise of NCHIs across Europe calls for a reevaluation of these policies. Law enforcement should not be tasked with monitoring thoughts or feelings. Guidelines must be clarified to prevent the recording of incidents that are trivial, subjective, or clearly not motivated by deliberate hostility.

European governments must also stop conflating legitimate criticism with hate speech. While hate speech laws should target genuine incitement to violence, they are increasingly misused to silence dissent and shield political elites from scrutiny.

Protect Free Speech, Focus on Real Crimes

The examples of the nine-year-old and the schoolgirls underscore the absurdity of current policies. Policing speech this way not only squanders resources but also erodes public trust in government and law enforcement.

Europe must draw a line and reassert the importance of free expression. Without it, democracy itself risks becoming little more than a hollow shell, where citizens are too afraid to speak their minds for fear of repercussions.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Netanyahu Dismisses Shin Bet Chief Amid 'Loss of Trust' and 'Qatargate' Corruption Investigations Involving Netanyahu's Advisors
UK Conservatives Remain Optimistic Despite Polling Challenges
Labour MPs Unveil Initiative to Combat Harmful Influencers and Advocate for Healthy Masculinity
Miami Beach Mayor Cancels Plan to Expel Cinema Following Documentary Showing
Thousands of Drones Illuminate the Sky in Honor of Trump.
Leaders of the US and Ukraine Participate in Constructive Call During Ongoing Conflict
Elon Musk's X Experiences Valuation Recovery to $44 billion.
UK Government Set to Implement Major Budget Cuts in Spring Statement
US Federal Reserve Downgrades Economic Growth Outlook Due to Tariff Uncertainty
EU Claims US Tech Giants Have Violated Digital Regulations
Canada Denounces the Execution of Its Citizens in China Amid Rising Tensions
European Union Moves Toward Joint Debt for Military Spending
Mass Protests in Belgrade Against Serbian President and Government
UK Small Businesses Express Discontent Over Labour's Tax Policies
European Industry Leaders Urge EU to Enhance Technological Sovereignty
Serbia Witnesses Unprecedented Protests Following Novi Sad Railway Station Collapse
China Introduces 'Zhulong' C-14 Nuclear Battery Expected to Last 5,730 Years
Inquiry: Social Media Platforms Greenlit Advertisements Featuring Anti-Semitic and Anti-Muslim Material in Germany
U.S. Expels South African Diplomat Amid Escalating Tensions Over Discriminatory Land Seizure Policies
High-Ranking ISIS Official Slain in Collaborative Operation in Iraq
After countless Ukrainian lives lost, the nation in ruins, the economy in shambles, and vast numbers of the population having fled, NATO has "Announced" that Ukraine's membership is no longer being considered.
Connecticut Woman Accused of Keeping Stepson Imprisoned for Twenty Years
Bosnia and Herzegovina Encounters Political Turmoil Following Arrest Warrant Issued for Serb Leader
Meta Set to Introduce Community Notes Feature in March as Part of New Content Moderation Approach
Trump Family in Discussions for Investment in Binance
UK Prime Minister Suggests Significant Changes to the Governance of the National Health Service.
France Takes Strong Stance Against Potential US Tariffs on Alcoholic Drinks
Donatella Versace to Resign as Creative Director Following Almost 30 Years.
Trump's Ambassador Nominee Confirmed Canada’s Autonomy in the Face of Trade Strains
Netanyahu Rejects UN Conclusions on Gaza as 'Untrue'
Trump Speaks on the Possibility of a Ukraine Ceasefire Amid Continued Tensions
Trump Reaffirms Interest in Greenland Acquisition Amid Geopolitical Issues
French Prime Minister Bayrou Declares Position Against US Tariff Menaces
These are currently increasing in the UK.
Trump's Encounter with the Irish Prime Minister Takes an Unforeseen Twist Regarding Fashion and Economic Matters.
Isabel, a Russian native, wed Zahid Ali Khan, describing it as "love at first sight." She adores him for his character, not his $740 million fortune.
Chair Refers to Transgender Representative as 'Mr. McBride' During Congressional Meeting
The ICC's Revenge on Behalf of Drug Dealers, Against Philippine President Duterte, Who Fought Them and Saved 100 Million Filipinos from the Drugs-Death Industry—ignoring the fact that every victory comes at a cost
Canada Expresses Concerns Regarding U.S. Trade Policies Before G7 Meeting
FBI Alerts of Increasing Smishing Scams Aiming at Mobile Users
World Bank Officials Facing Examination for Travel-Related Carbon Emissions
EU and Canada Declare Countermeasures in Response to U.S. Steel and Aluminum Tariffs
Tiger Woods and Elin Nordegren: An In-Depth Exploration of Their Marital Struggles and Current Co-Parenting Efforts
Ex-Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte Detained in Manila Under ICC Warrant
Mark Carney Chosen as Head of Canada's Liberal Party, Poised to Assume Role of Prime Minister
Russia Kicks Out British Diplomats in Escalated Tensions
Significant Rescue Effort in Progress Following Collision Between Tanker and Cargo Ship in the North Sea
Pope Francis Exhibits Signs of Recovery, Yet Remains Hospitalized
Report of Radioactive Coolant Leak at Europe’s Largest Nuclear Reactor
Trump Administration Launches Self-Deportation App for Undocumented Immigrants
×