London Daily

Focus on the big picture.

The Supreme Court allowed a transgender girl to continue playing sports, but a Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas dissent signals their willingness to review the hot-button issue

The Supreme Court allowed a transgender girl to continue playing sports, but a Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas dissent signals their willingness to review the hot-button issue

Alito and Thomas wrote that the dispute "concerns an important issue that this Court is likely to be required to address in the near future."
A majority of the Supreme Court on Thursday allowed a transgender girl to continue participating on her middle school's girls' track team as a legal case challenging a state ban plays out. Yet two conservative justices — Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas — dissented from the decision, suggesting the court may soon wade into the Republican-led culture war over trans athletes.

Alito, in an opinion joined by Thomas, wrote that the dispute "concerns an important issue that this Court is likely to be required to address in the near future," particularly, whether states can restrict "participation in women's or girls' sports based on genes or physiological or anatomical characteristics."

The two justices, widely considered to be the court's most conservative members, said they would have granted West Virginia's request to enforce a law requiring students to play on sports teams based on their biological sex. The law prevents transgender students from participating in athletics that correspond with their gender identities.

Becky Pepper-Jackson, a 12-year-old transgender girl on her school's track team, challenged the April 2021 law, known as the Save Women's Sports Act, in a May 2021 lawsuit. Her lawyers argued that the ban violated the Constitution's 14th Amendment, which guarantees equal protection, as well as Title IX, the 1972 federal law that prohibits sex-based discrimination.

A federal district judge initially stopped West Virginia from enforcing the law, letting Pepper-Jackson play on the team, but eventually sided with the state. Pepper-Jackson appealed the decision, and a divided panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit temporarily blocked the law.

West Virginia then turned to the Supreme Court to lift that ruling. But in its decision Thursday, a majority of the justices refused to do so. The court did not provide an explanation, which is typical for cases brought to its emergency docket.

"I would grant the State's application," Alito and Thomas said in their dissent. "Among other things, enforcement of the law at issue should not be forbidden by the federal courts without any explanation."

The majority of the justices' refusal to intervene in the case at this stage, and the two justices' dissent, signal that the court may later consider the hot-button issue winding its way through lower courts.

West Virginia is among a slew of Republican-led states that have enacted restrictions on transgender students from playing on athletic teams that align with their gender identities. In a statement on Thursday, West Virginia's attorney general expressed disappointment with the Supreme Court's order.

"This is a procedural setback, but we remain confident that when this case is ultimately determined on the merits, we will prevail," Attorney General Patrick Morrisey said. "We maintain our stance that this is a common sense law—we have a very strong case. It's just basic fairness and common sense to not have biological males play in women's sports."
Comments

Oh ya 1 year ago
There are 2 genders boys and girls, and then there are a million mental health issues. Of the wotld is afraid of offending the mentally ill then make a 3rd class in sports. We could have boy sports, girl sports and then mentally ill sports. We have all heard the saying putting lipstick on a pig but even that does not make it a girl or in fact a boy in drag

Newsletter

Related Articles

London Daily
0:00
0:00
Close
Kate Middleton's Public Absence Throughout 2024
Asylum Seekers Arriving In UK by Sea Exceed 10,000 This Year
UK Criticizes ICJ Order on Israel's Rafah Assault
Ukraine's Fight Against Corruption Gains Ground Amid War
Czech President Petr Pavel Injured in Motorcycle Accident
Record Number of Abortions in England and Wales
Paul McCartney Honours Bruce Springsteen at Ivor Novello Awards
US and UK to Reject ICJ Ruling on Israel's Rafah Offensive
World Court Orders Immediate Halt to Israeli Offensive in Gaza
Understanding FLiRT COVID Variants and Their Impact
Baltic NATO Members to Construct 'Drone Wall'
Global Life Expectancy Dropped By 2 Years Due To COVID-19
Macron Halts New Caledonia Voting Reform After Riots
Rishi Sunak Shelves Rwanda and Smoking Policies Ahead of Election
US Refuses World Court Jurisdiction
China Conducts Surprise Military Drills Around Taiwan
Grim Polls Predict Major Loss for PM Rishi Sunak
Rishi Sunak's Campaign for UK Election: Key Issues Highlighted
German Property Crisis Worsens as Foreign Investment Declines
Princess of Wales's Taskforce Calls for Business Investment in Early Childhood
Campaign Groups Condemn UK Report on Protests
Former Royal Marine Charged with Espionage Found Dead
Australian PM Calls for Julian Assange's Freedom
ICC Seeks Arrest Warrants for Israeli and Hamas Leaders
UK's Infected Blood Scandal: Conclusion Nears After Seven Years
Julian Assange Granted Right to Challenge US Extradition
Congo Army Thwarts Attempted Coup Involving Americans and a British Citizen
Ireland's Homeless Gain Voting Rights
Blinken orders crackdown on Israel-Hamas leaks
Julian Assange Faces US Extradition: Key Facts
Jacob Zuma Takes Campaign to ANC Stronghold Soweto
Attempted Assassination of Slovakia PM Robert Fico: Investigation Ongoing
What Happens If an Iranian President Dies in Office?
Spain Recalls Ambassador After Argentina President's Remarks
Rishi Sunak Faces Cabinet Backlash Over Proposed Changes to Foreign Student Visas
Rwanda Denies Entry to Human Rights Researcher
Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi Reportedly Killed in Helicopter Crash
Blue Origin Resumes Space Tourism with 90-Year-Old Ed Dwight
Rishi Sunak and Wife Akshata Murty Wealthier Than King Charles
New Dutch Government Drives Wedge Through EU Liberals
Iranian President Raisi Missing After Helicopter Goes Down
Freemasons and ‘Global War Party’ Accused of Conspiring Against Georgia
Poland Supports Rolls-Royce's Nuclear Power Plant Initiative
European Ports Overflow with Unsold Electric Vehicles
Esprit Files for Bankruptcy in Europe, Putting Hundreds of Jobs at Risk
Chevron Halts North Sea Drilling Amid Rising Tax Burden
Jeremy Hunt Accused of Exaggerating Conservatives' Economic Record
Victoria Atkins Discusses Historical Gender Bias in the NHS
Dublin and Monaghan Bombings 50th Anniversary: Calls for Justice
Rishi Sunak and Akshata Murty’s Wealth Rises to £651 Million
×