London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Sunday, Aug 02, 2026

Mnuchin is wrong: Amazon has done more good than bad for small business

Mnuchin is wrong: Amazon has done more good than bad for small business

Gene Marks
The treasury secretary said Amazon ‘destroyed the retail industry’ – but Amazon has created businesses, side hustles, development and content design opportunities for more than 1.9m small businesses and entrepreneurs around the world who, in turn, have created more than 1.6m jobs in the process. The company has created a special site just for people to buy from small businesses and another one to help aspiring entrepreneurs become partners and merchants. More than half the items sold on their site is sold by a small- or medium-sized company, and countless other consultants, technology companies, logistics firms, warehousing landlords and other small businesses have created their livelihoods on Amazon’s back.

Take a walk today down New York City’s Seventh Avenue – or any Main Street in small-town America – and you’ll see that things look a lot different than they did 40 or even 20 years ago.

Back then there were lots of retail stores selling shoes, clothes, sporting equipment and books. Today … not so much. The malls are empty, name-brand chains have shut down and storefronts are more or less occupied by “experience” businesses – restaurants, coffee shops, bars, exercise places or nail salons. Where did retail go? Has it been destroyed? And did Amazon cause all of this?

Yes, Amazon caused a lot of it. In fact, the e-commerce giant changed retail forever. But it’s not all bad news – particularly for small businesses.

Steve Mnuchin doesn’t feel this way. In an interview with CNBC this week, the treasury secretary (and former Sears board member) said that Amazon has “destroyed the retail industry across the United States”. He also said that “no question they’ve limited competition. People had those concerns about Walmart, but Walmart developed a business where small business could continue to compete with them.”

Mnuchin knows a lot more about a lot of things than me. I would never debate him on tax policy, the federal debt ceiling or anything to do with the US government’s finances. But, with all due respect, small business is my turf, not his. And when it comes to small business I do feel comfortable saying this: Amazon is not hurting small businesses. It is actually quite the opposite.

I’m not an employee at Amazon, and although my firm has done some marketing work for the company over the past few years I am not an Amazon merchant or partner. I just know a lot about small businesses because I run one and I write about them. And when it comes to small businesses, Amazon has done way more good than bad.

The company has created businesses, side hustles, development and content design opportunities for more than 1.9m small businesses and entrepreneurs around the world who, in turn, have created more than 1.6m jobs in the process. The company has created a special site just for people to buy from small businesses and another one to help aspiring entrepreneurs become partners and merchants. More than half the items sold on their site is sold by a small- or medium-sized company, and countless other consultants, technology companies, logistics firms, warehousing landlords and other small businesses have created their livelihoods on Amazon’s back.

You’re not seeing these people on Main Street anymore, but trust me, they’re still out there … and in droves. They’re selling to customers they could never dreamed of, reaching and sourcing products from suppliers in faraway places, and doing this all from the comfort of their homes or from spaces that cost a helluva lot less than rent on Seventh Avenue.

“Amazon is the first partner that offers small businesses a legitimate way to compete with the big retailers – which is why they are scared, and why they are sounding the alarm that it’s ‘killing retail’,” Jerry Kozak, the owner of Ann Arbor T-shirt Company and an Amazon merchant, told me. “Amazon is changing retail by offering more products from more merchants, at greater convenience – and people are voting with their wallets.”

Kozak, who employs 75 people at his $20m a year business, isn’t alone in his support of the online platform. Many other business owners I know agree with him.

And by the way, Amazon isn’t the only game in town. E-commerce applications that allow small businesses to sell from their own websites such as Shopify, BigCommerce and Magento have exploded in popularity over the past few years. Etsy, eBay and other online marketplaces have attracted countless small businesses to sell and Chinese giant Alibaba just announced this week new tools particularly for small businesses that make up part of its strategy to grow in the American market. Small businesses have plenty of choices to sell their wares other than Amazon.

And sell they do. On Amazon’s Prime Day alone, small- and medium-sized companies sold more than $2bn of products, a 33% increase over last year. The other platforms have also helped small businesses generate billions in revenues.

“What Amazon has actually done is democratize retail and leveled the playing field so that independent brands and small businesses can enter the market and thrive,” Kristin Rae, an Amazon merchant who owns Inspire Travel Luggage, said. “Truly, I wouldn’t be able to be a business without Amazon.”

Yes, retail has undergone an enormous change, and Amazon has been a big part of that. But the smart entrepreneurs I know – like Kozak and Rae – understand something that some slow-reacting retailers, disconnected politicians and yes, even a treasury secretary hasn’t: it’s 2019 and not 1979. They’re profiting, and good for them.

Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Finland Deploys Commercial-Scale Thermal Batteries Using Crushed Rock to Store Renewable Grid Energy
Valued at $109 Million: F-35B Fighter Jet Crashes in Southern California
Sainsbury Agrees to Sell Argos in £120 Million Deal to Private Consortium
High Court Clears Way for Construction of Chinese Embassy at Royal Mint Court
UK Fuel Prices Climb to Multi-Month Highs as Strait of Hormuz Tensions Disrupt Oil Supplies
Severe Summer Drought and Record Heat Put UK Harvests at Risk
Prime Minister Andy Burnham Faces Labour Backbench Opposition Over Potential Support for New North Sea Oil and Gas Drilling
Bank of England Warns Inflation Will Stay Above 3% as Middle East Energy Shock Prolongs Cost-of-Living Pressures
Andy Burnham has Announces Plans to Redistribute Income Tax Revenue to English Mayors
Early-Release Scheme Faces Fresh Scrutiny as Reoffending and Prison Recalls Rise
Police Phone Checks Followed Report on Murder of MI5 Agent Inside Sinn Féin
Archbishop of Canterbury Reaffirms £100 Million Reparative Justice Fund During Ghana Visit
Charities Allege French Police Used Tear Gas Against Channel Migrants
Norwegian Teenager Convicted Over Iran-Linked Murder Plot in Britain
Christian Organisations File Charity Complaints Against Amnesty International UK
Ofgem Tightens Grid Connection Rules for New Data Centres
FTSE 100 Reaches Record High Despite Global Technology Sell-Off
Millions of UK Households Urged to Check Eligibility for Winter Energy Discount
Labour Restores Parliamentary Whips to Diane Abbott and Joani Reid
UK Supreme Court to Hear Challenge Over Palestine Action Ban
UK Commits More Than £8.4 Billion to Dreadnought Nuclear Submarine Programme
England Declares Severe Drought as Wildfire Burns Near Sizewell Nuclear Site
Bank of England Holds Interest Rates at 3.75% as Middle East Tensions Fuel Inflation Risks
Drought Status Extended Across All of Wales as Heat and Dry Weather Deepen Environmental Strain
Record-Low Danube Exposes Probable Mammoth Remains in Bulgaria
UK Business Confidence Climbs to Four-Month High
Greater Manchester Gains Expanded Powers Under Regional Funding Reforms
UK Supreme Court to Hear Appeal Over Palestine Action Terror Ban
Shell's Quarterly Profit Doubles to Nearly $10 Billion on Higher Energy Prices
UK Government Removes VAT From Household Electricity Bills
Exceptional Drought Grips Half of England as Wildfire Threatens Sizewell
Bank of England Holds Interest Rates at 3.75% as Inflation Risks Persist
US Says It Has Carried Out Heavy Strikes on Iran After Attempted Attacks on Its Forces
The chief executive of the popular gaming company laid off many employees and his pay rose to 38 million dollars
UK Employment Holds Steady as Wage Growth Remains Moderate
England to Introduce Artificial Intelligence into Secondary School Curriculum
Wales Launches £1.2 Billion Industrial Regeneration Programme
High Court Upholds UK Digital Surveillance Framework
Northern Ireland Reaches Budget Agreement on Infrastructure and Public Sector Pay
Home Office Expands Digital Border Checks Nationwide
UK Approves Major North Sea Wind and Carbon Capture Project
The World's Most Terrifying Smartphone: Recording, Documenting, and Reporting to the Regime
Scotland Approves Major Renewable Energy Expansion
UK and United States Sign AI and Semiconductor Cooperation Pact
UK Treasury Tightens Fiscal Controls After Gilt Market Volatility
Bank of England Holds Interest Rates at 4.5%
UK Unveils £10 Billion NHS Funding Overhaul and Workforce Reform
The AI User Nightmare: Private Claude Conversations Leaked to the Internet
UK: Former Football Association Leaders Call for World Cup Boycott Over FIFA Privatization Plan
Forbidden Love: China severs millions from their virtual partners
×