London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Monday, Sep 08, 2025

Nicola Sturgeon faces fortnight of criticism over trans prisons policy

Nicola Sturgeon faces fortnight of criticism over trans prisons policy

Critics claim her career is ‘over,’ while trans Scots worry about sensationalised coverage after trans rapist put in women’s prison
Few can be anticipating Holyrood’s recess next week as keenly as Nicola Sturgeon.

She has endured a fortnight of relentless and increasingly personal criticism, punishing headlines and lacklustre polling. Meanwhile, her critics in the media have declared her career is “over”.

And her former mentor Alex Salmond has accused her of “throwing away” the impetus for Scottish independence with the focus on her gender recognition reforms.

All of this was provoked by reports that a newly convicted transgender woman Isla Bryson – who committed two rapes while living as a man, Adam Graham – was being initially assessed in the women-only prison Cornton Vale.

Although Bryson was moved to a male prison less than 72 hours later, after Sturgeon herself made it plain “a rapist should not be in a woman’s prison”, the public outcry has not abated. The furore escalated after similar cases emerged, and former inmates of Cornton Vale described their distress at sharing facilities with individuals with male genitalia.

Opponents of the Scottish government’s gender recognition changes – self-identification for those who wish to change legal sex – have seized on the row as vindicating their concerns about lack of safeguards in the bill, which the UK government blocked it from going for royal assent last month because of “safety issues for women and children”. They have called for Sturgeon to be held personally accountable for endangering vulnerable women.

Meanwhile, transgender Scots report the personal cost of sensationalised coverage, as monitoring groups warn of a spike in hate crime that typically follows such focus.

The Scottish Prison Service insists it was following a policy put in place nearly a decade ago, but it would seem that the treatment of sex offenders and gender recognition are now inextricably linked in the public consciousness. Ipsos polling held after the Bryson story broke found 50% of those surveyed support the UK government’s decision to block the gender bill, which is striking given it had cross-party support.

Although every party leader at Holyrood, bar the Scottish Conservative’s Douglas Ross, supported the plans and similar proposals are being brought by Welsh Labour, the ongoing controversy is seen by many as a referendum on Sturgeon’s leadership and priorities.

Asked at every opportunity to state whether Isla Bryon is a man or a woman, Sturgeon – a politician celebrated for her communication skills – has delivered a series of uncharacteristically faltering responses, both in ascribing gender and hinting she agreed with reports Bryson was likely gaming the system. It is a question which plenty of other politicians and campaigners admit privately they dread being asked, but also one that LGBTQ+ allies argue only serves to undermine the identity of all trans people.

What is clear that to all those involved is that this row – in particular the image of Bryson outside court in a blond wig – has cut through to voters in a way that the detail of gender recognition reform did not. But by how much?

Polling for the Sunday Times last weekend found a dip in support for the SNP and Sturgeon – though still well ahead of all other parties and leaders – although no specific questions were asked on trans policy and disengagement could as easily be ascribed to the cost of living, school strikes or NHS failings.

Scottish government sources maintain that, while the past few weeks have been “very difficult”, the controversy is unlikely to “shift the tectonic plates” of voting intention. They point out that the first minister has weathered heavier storms, most notably the inquiry the Scottish government’s handling of sexual harassment allegations against her predecessor Salmond.

Salmond, who is urging against a court challenge to the UK government over the blocked gender bill, himself lost no time in attacking his successor for her focus on “self-indulgent nonsense”.

But it is not only the former first minister warning against linking independence to an increasingly divisive cause. It marks a divergence too from the usual strategy of easy-does-it-until-independence, in order to keep a broad coalition onside. In public and private the repeated question is: why choose this hill to die on?

For others, the answer is simple: Sturgeon passionately believes this is the next right thing to do in terms of equalities reform, and will not be swayed by an accelerating culture war.

But James Mitchell, professor of public policy at Edinburgh University, insists the furore of the past week exemplifies a rigid approach to government.

“Sturgeon is a campaigner and those skills are not appropriate for government, which requires long-term planning, accepting that things can get difficult, and that you have to convince people while also respecting them,” he said

The current focus on gender matters may turn off voters who are more concerned about their gas bills, suggests Adam Tomkins, professor of public law at Glasgow University and former Scottish Conservative MSP. “A lot of people will have noticed this is the only subject of Scottish political conversation over the last month and that allows the impression to fester that the Scottish government’s priorities are not the people’s priorities,” he said.

There are certainly those in the SNP’s Holyrood group who express weariness and frustration that, after the gruelling bill process, there remains “no end in sight”.

And this speaks to wider internal criticisms of how the SNP operates: hyper-managed, with a limited inner circle and little space for dissent – it’s notable that new Westminster leader Stephen Flynn was keen to assure the Guardian last week that internal disagreements should be respected.

A special party conference is planned for March to debate Sturgeon’s plan to run the next general or Holyrood election as a de facto referendum, after the supreme court ruled that only the UK government could allow another independence poll.

And now dissent is spilling forth whether the leadership like it or not. Two senior SNP figures, previously loyalist MP Stewart McDonald, and former Holyrood health secretary Alex Neil on Wednesday urged SNP members to reject the de facto proposal and party insiders anticipate further ructions before the vote.

But one equalities campaigner points out that the impact of the prisons row goes well beyond what it means for one politician or party: “What does it mean for Scotland and the minorities of all kinds living in it, where it’s now acceptable to dismiss inclusivity as ‘nonsense’?”
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Nayib Bukele Points Out Belgian Hypocrisy as Brussels Considers Sending Army into the Streets
Elon Musk Poised to Become First Trillionaire Under Ambitious Tesla Pay Plan
France, at an Impasse, Heads Toward Another Government Collapse
Burning the Minister’s House Helped Protesters to Win Justice: Prabowo Fires Finance Minister in Wake of Indonesia Protests
Brazil Braces for Fallout from Bolsonaro Trial by corrupted judge
The Country That Got Too Rich? Public Spending Dominates Norway Election
Nearly 40 Years Later: Nike Changes the Legendary Slogan Just Do It
Generations Born After 1939 Unlikely to Reach Age One Hundred, New Study Finds
End to a four-year manhunt in New Zealand: the father who abducted his children to the forests was killed, the three siblings were found
Germany Suspends Debt Rules, Funnels €500 Billion Toward Military and Proxy War Strategy
EU Prepares for War
BMW Eyes Growth in China with New All‑Electric Neue Klasse Lineup
Trump Threatens Retaliatory Tariffs After EU Imposes €2.95 Billion Fine on Google
Tesla Board Proposes Unprecedented One-Trillion-Dollar Performance Package for Elon Musk
US Justice Department Launches Criminal Mortgage-Fraud Probe into Federal Reserve Governor Lisa Cook
Escalating Drug Trafficking and Violence in Latin America: A Growing Crisis
US and Taiwanese Defence Officials Held Secret Talks in Alaska
Report: Secret SEAL Team 6 Mission in North Korea Ordered by Trump in 2019 Ended in Failure
Gold Could Reach Nearly $5,000 if Fed Independence Is Undermined, Goldman Sachs Warns
Uruguay, Colombia and Paraguay Secure Places at 2026 World Cup
Florida Murder Case: The Adelson Family, the Killing of Dan Markel, and the Trial of Donna Adelson
Trump Administration Advances Plans to Rebrand Pentagon as Department of War Instead of the Fake Term Department of Defense
Big Tech Executives Laud Trump at White House Dinner, Unveil Massive U.S. Investments
Tether Expands into Gold Sector with Profit-Driven Diversification
‘Looks Like a Wig’: Online Users Express Concern Over Kate Middleton
Brand-New $1 Million Yacht Sinks Just Fifteen Minutes After Maiden Launch in Turkey
Here’s What the FBI Seized in John Bolton Raid — and the Legal Risks He Faces
Florida’s Vaccine Revolution: DeSantis Declares War on Mandates
Trump’s New War – and the ‘Drug Tyrant’ Fearing Invasion: ‘1,200 Missiles Aimed at Us’
"The Situation Has Never Been This Bad": The Fall of PepsiCo
At the Parade in China: Laser Weapons, 'Eagle Strike,' and a Missile Capable of 'Striking Anywhere in the World'
The Fashion Designer Who Became an Italian Symbol: Giorgio Armani Has Died at 91
Putin Celebrates ‘Unprecedentedly High’ Ties with China as Gazprom Seals Power of Siberia-2 Deal
China Unveils New Weapons in Grand Military Parade as Xi Hosts Putin and Kim
Queen Camilla’s Teenage Courage: Fended Off Attempted Assault on London Train, New Biography Reveals
Scottish Brothers Set Record in Historic Pacific Row
Rapper Cardi B Cleared of Liability in Los Angeles Civil Assault Trial
Google Avoids Break-Up in U.S. Antitrust Case as Stocks Rise
Couple celebrates 80th wedding anniversary at assisted living facility in Lancaster
Information Warfare in the Age of AI: How Language Models Become Targets and Tools
The White House on LinkedIn Has Changed Their Profile Picture to Donald Trump
"Insulted the Prophet Muhammad": Woman Burned Alive by Angry Mob in Niger State, Nigeria
Trump Responds to Death Rumors – Announces 'Missile City'
Court of Appeal Allows Asylum Seekers to Remain at Essex Hotel Amid Local Tax Boycott Threats
Germany in Turmoil: Ukrainian Teenage Girl Pushed to Death by Illegal Iraqi Migrant
United Krack down on human rights: Graham Linehan Arrested at Heathrow Over Three X Posts, Hospitalised, Released on Bail with Posting Ban
Asian and Middle Eastern Investors Avoid US Markets
Ray Dalio Warns of US Shift to Autocracy
Eurozone Inflation Rises to 2.1% in August
Russia and China Sign New Gas Pipeline Deal
×