London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Saturday, Feb 22, 2025

After the Uber ruling, there's no excuse for government not to enforce workers' rights

After the Uber ruling, there's no excuse for government not to enforce workers' rights

For too long the Conservatives have left workplace protections to the whims of employers, with awful consequences
In 2018, Ali submitted a claim against Uber for unpaid holidays. Originally from Somaliland, he had been driving for Uber since 2016, a couple of years after arriving in the UK. Since then, he hadn’t had a single paid holiday, despite at times working up to 70 hours in a seven-day week. He had taken some time off though – once for a couple weeks on the doctor’s recommendation to address his (unsurprising) back pain. When he tried to get assistance from the Uber-provided insurance policy the company likes to boast about, he was told the time off wouldn’t be covered.

Despite an employment tribunal ruling as far back as 2016 that Uber drivers were entitled to basic protections such as minimum wage and paid holidays, Ali’s claim has been on hold while Uber continued to appeal the decision. Throughout the years of appeals, Uber denied these protections to its drivers. On Friday, however, six justices of the supreme court gave the final decision on the lead Uber case and, like the three rulings that came before it, held that Uber drivers are entitled to basic workers’ rights.

It’s not been an easy ride for Uber; the contractual arguments it urged on the tribunals and courts were rejected wholesale, at times with scorn. Uber’s legal case, at its most basic, is that the company is a “platform”, connecting riders and drivers. It earns its money not by transporting passengers, but rather by charging drivers – who it calls its “customers” – a fee for acting as the drivers’ agent and generating business leads (passenger rides) for them. When the employment tribunal first ruled in this case, however, it stated: “The notion that Uber in London is a mosaic of 30,000 small businesses linked by a common ‘platform’ is to our minds faintly ridiculous.”

The court of appeal referred to “the high degree of fiction in the wording” of Uber’s contractual documents, as well as to “the air of contrivance and artificiality which pervades Uber’s case”. The supreme court also rejected Uber’s contracts as showing that the drivers were not entitled to basic workers’ rights, noting that: “Laws such as the National Minimum Wage Act were manifestly enacted to protect those whom parliament considers to be in need of protection and not just those who are designated by their employer as qualifying for it.”

In practice, however, successive Tory governments have largely left it to employers to decide which workers should qualify for employment rights. Few workers’ rights are enforced by any state body, leaving enforcement to the tribunals and courts after individual workers or unions submit claims. But even that was too much of a threat to business interests for the Tories; the coalition government clamped down on this by removing the rights of individuals to bring tribunal claims over breaches of health and safety statutes – part of David Cameron’s attempt to “kill off the health and safety culture for good” – and they introduced tribunal fees, which led to a massive reduction in claims.

The fees were later struck down by the supreme court; the court stated that without unimpeded access to the courts, “laws are liable to become a dead letter, the work done by parliament may be rendered nugatory, and the democratic election of members of parliament may become a meaningless charade.”

But beyond government attempts to restrain individual workers from asserting their rights, the few state agencies or departments that are mandated to enforce the law at work often do an abysmal job. David Metcalf, the former director of Labour Market Enforcement, pointed out that companies could expect a minimum wage inspection once every 500 years, and that around £1.8bn worth of holidays went unpaid each year. To his credit he made a number of suggestions on how to address this, the most useful of which were rejected by Theresa May’s government. Failing to make significant progress, he stepped down after less than three years.

Metcalf was replaced by Matthew Taylor, whose 2017 Taylor Review – which made a series of recommendations to the government on how to address precarious employment – was largely dismissed by trade unions as not going anywhere near far enough. Notably, it had almost nothing to say about the role of enforcement in protecting workers’ rights. But even Taylor has proved too much of a challenge for this government; his term has not been extended, despite him offering to stay on unpaid until a replacement was found, leaving the post vacant for several months. “The whole thing is incompetent, irresponsible and suggests a disregard for vulnerable workers,” Taylor tweeted about the debacle.

Not even a pandemic killing thousands is enough to force a rethink in approach: despite there being more than 3,500 workplace outbreaks of coronavirus, the Health and Safety Executive has failed to shut down or prosecute a single employer, preferring instead methods of “direct persuasion, advice and reprimand”.

The government’s utter disinterest in applying the law is certainly not lost on Uber. Indeed, in response to the ruling, Uber has already sought to downplay its significance, saying it only “focused on a small number of drivers”, leaving open the possibility that it wasn’t relevant to its thousands of current drivers as a number of changes had since been made to the app. Pursuing this path would be a slap in the face to Ali, who hoped the supreme court ruling would mean he finally has rights. It would be “very good news if we got our rights from 2016,” he tells me. “I hope we will get them now.”

With the supreme court’s decision, Uber has reached the end of the journey and it’s too late to cancel the trip. It’s now time for the government to make them pay. Ali and tens of thousands of his co-workers are waiting.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
UK Prison Officer Sentenced for Inappropriate Conduct with Inmate
Good News: Senate Confirms Kash Patel as FBI Director
Officials from the U.S. and Hungary Engage in Talks on Economic Collaboration and Sanctions Strategy
James Bond Franchise Transitions to Amazon MGM Studios
Technology Giants Ramp Up Lobbying Initiatives Against Strict EU Regulations
Alibaba Exceeds Quarterly Projections Fueled by Growth in Cloud and AI
Tequila Sector Faces Surplus Crisis as Agave Prices Dive Sharply
Residents of Flintshire Mobile Home Park Grapple with Maintenance Issues and Uncertain Future
Ronan Keating Criticizes Irish Justice System Following Fatal Crash Involving His Brother
Gordon Ramsay's Lucky Cat Restaurant Faces Unprecedented Theft
Israeli Family Mourns Loss of Peace Advocate Oded Lifschitz as Body Returned from Gaza
Former UK Defense Chief Calls for Enhanced European Support for Ukraine
Pope Francis Admitted to Hospital in Rome Amid Rising Succession Speculation
Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell, at the age of 83, Declares His Retirement.
Whistleblower Reveals Whitehall’s Focus on Kabul Animal Airlift Amid Crisis
Politicians Who Deliberately Lie Could Face Removal from Office in Wales
Scottish Labour Faces Challenges Ahead of 2026 Holyrood Elections
Leftwing Activists Less Likely to Work with Political Rivals, Study Finds
Boris Johnson to Host 'An Evening with Boris Johnson' at Edinburgh's Usher Hall
Planned Change in British Citizenship Rules Faces First Legal Challenge
Northumberland Postal Worker Sentenced for Sexual Assaults During Deliveries
British Journalist Missing in Brazil for 11 Days
Tesco Fixes Website Glitch That Disrupted Online Grocery Orders
Amnesty International Critiques UK's Predictive Policing Practices
Burglar Jailed After Falling into Home-Made Trap in Blyth
Sellafield Nuclear Site Exits Special Measures for Physical Security Amid Ongoing Cybersecurity Concerns
Avian Influenza Impact on Seals in Norfolk: Four Deaths Confirmed
First Arrest Under Scotland's Abortion Clinic Buffer Zone Law Amidst International Controversy
Meghan Markle Rebrands Lifestyle Venture as 'As Ever' Ahead of Netflix Series Launch
Inter-Island Ferry Services Between Guernsey and Jersey Set to Expand
Significant Proportion of Cancer Patients in England and Wales Not Receiving Recommended Treatments
Final Consultation Launched for Vyrnwy Frankton Power Line Project
Drug Misuse Deaths in Scotland Rise by 12% in 2023
Failed £100 Million Cocaine Smuggling Operation in the Scottish Highlands
Central Cee Equals MOBO Awards Record; Bashy and Ayra Starr Among Top Honorees
EastEnders: Four Decades of Challenging Social Norms
Jonathan Bailey Channels 'Succession' in Bold Richard II Performance
Northern Ireland's First Astronaut Engages in Rigorous Spacewalk Training
Former Postman Sentenced for Series of Sexual Offences in Northumberland
Record Surge in Anti-Muslim Hate Crimes Across the UK in 2024
Omagh Bombing Inquiry Concludes Commemorative Hearings with Survivor Testimonies
UK Government Introduces 'Ronan's Law' to Combat Online Knife Sales to Minors
Metal Detectorists Unearth 15th-Century Coin Hoard in Scottish Borders
Woman Charged in 1978 Death of Five-Year-Old Girl in South London
Expanding Sinkhole in Godstone, Surrey, Forces Evacuations and Road Closures
Bangor University Announces Plans to Cut 200 Jobs Amid £15 Million Savings Target
British Journalist Charlotte Peet Reported Missing in Brazil
UK Inflation Rises to 3% in January Amid Higher Food Prices and School Fees
Starmer Defends Zelensky Amidst Trump's 'Dictator' Allegation
Zelensky Calls on World Leaders to Back Peace Efforts in Light of Strains with Trump
×