London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Wednesday, Jul 23, 2025

2 transgender men in court fight over changing sex on Hong Kong ID cards

2 transgender men in court fight over changing sex on Hong Kong ID cards

They had their breasts removed, received hormonal treatment and live as men, but the government requires they undergo full sex reassignment surgery to have the sex on their ID cards changed.

A person does not have to undergo complete sex reassignment surgery to be considered as having changed into a man or woman, lawyers for two transgender men have told Hong Kong’s High Court.

The court began hearing their appeal on Monday against a ruling that backed a government policy on how a person’s sex can be switched on identification cards. They argue the official requirement that a full sex change is needed is unethical and degrading.

But the counsel for the Commissioner of Registration countered that Mr Justice Thomas Au Hing-cheung was right in finding the requirement was “the only workable model” that was “fair to everyone and the public interest” when officers decide on applications seeking to make the change.

Henry Edward Tse protests the High Court’s decision to refuse a judicial review over the policy in February 2019.


Au dismissed applications for a judicial review from Henry Edward Tse and a person identified only as Q in 2019 after they were unable to switch the designation from female to male. This was despite having their breasts removed, receiving hormonal treatment and living as men, although they have both retained their uteruses and ovaries and decided against undergoing surgery to construct genitals of the opposite sex.

Dinah Rose QC, for the appellants, said the courts and human rights bodies around the world had concluded making full surgery a precondition for recognition of a sex change was contrary to human rights.

“There is only one exception and that is the decision of Mr Justice Au, which is the subject of this appeal,” she said via videoconferencing from Britain. “That is a remarkable state of affairs.”

No factual basis existed to suggest Hong Kong’s situation was materially different from that of other jurisdictions, which had introduced other models of recognising the change, including the United States and Britain, Rose said.

She also noted the commissioner already recognised there were cases when the applicant was not required to complete the operation if he or she could not undergo the procedures for medical reasons.

Rose conceded her clients could undergo the surgery but argued it was unethical to require they do so after they had managed to deal with the distress that could arise from the incongruence between one’s expressed and assigned sex.

“It is inherently degrading to require people to go through surgery they have no medical need for,” she continued.

Rose added that female-to-male surgeries were significantly more complicated than the other way round, with a higher risk of failure, which explained why some transgender people avoid the procedure.

The appellants have maintained the requirement was an unjustified breach of Article 3 and 14 of the Hong Kong Bill of Rights, which protect a person from cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment, and the right to privacy, respectively.

They are seeking a court declaration the administrative policy was unconstitutional, which would pave the way for the commissioner to revise it.

Rose said the purpose of the identity card was to identify an individual, which in many daily situations had nothing to do with that person’s sex – but every one of those interactions exposed her clients to abuse and discrimination.

She suggested the commissioner could modify the policy by broadening the exception to include those who did not have a medical need for surgery or eliminating the requirement altogether.

Mr Justice Jeremy Poon Shiu-chor, the chief judge of the High Court, asked whether the government’s work in the Interdepartmental Working Group on Gender Recognition would affect the court’s analysis.

But Rose observed that nothing had happened in the four years since the group published a consultation paper on issues concerning recognition of a changed sex in 2017.

“It’s extremely unfortunate that having set up the [Interdepartmental Working Group], the process appears to have run into the sand,” she said. “There is no alternative but for the court to grapple with the problem because the problem is an urgent and continuous breach of fundamental rights.”

Monica Carss-Frisk QC, for the commissioner, countered that the group was preparing a report based on the analysis of the 18,800 responses received.

The government reply continues on Tuesday.

Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
US Treasury Secretary Calls for Institutional Review of Federal Reserve Amid AI‑Driven Growth Expectations
UK Government Considers Dropping Demand for Apple Encryption Backdoor
Severe Flooding in South Korea Claims Lives Amid Ongoing Rescue Operations
Japanese Man Discovers Family Connection Through DNA Testing After Decades of Separation
Russia Signals Openness to Ukraine Peace Talks Amid Escalating Drone Warfare
Switzerland Implements Ban on Mammography Screening
Japanese Prime Minister Vows to Stay After Coalition Loses Upper House Majority
Pogacar Extends Dominance with Stage Fifteen Triumph at Tour de France
CEO Resigns Amid Controversy Over Relationship with HR Executive
Man Dies After Being Pulled Into MRI Machine Due to Metal Chain in New York Clinic
NVIDIA Achieves $4 Trillion Valuation Amid AI Demand
US Revokes Visas of Brazilian Corrupted Judges Amid Fake Bolsonaro Investigation
U.S. Congress Approves Rescissions Act Cutting Federal Funding for NPR and PBS
North Korea Restricts Foreign Tourist Access to New Seaside Resort
Brazil's Supreme Court Imposes Radical Restrictions on Former President Bolsonaro
Centrist Criticism of von der Leyen Resurfaces as she Survives EU Confidence Vote
Judge Criticizes DOJ Over Secrecy in Dropping Charges Against Gang Leader
Apple Closes $16.5 Billion Tax Dispute With Ireland
Von der Leyen Faces Setback Over €2 Trillion EU Budget Proposal
UK and Germany Collaborate on Global Military Equipment Sales
Trump Plans Over 10% Tariffs on African and Caribbean Nations
Flying Taxi CEO Reclaims Billionaire Status After Stock Surge
Epstein Files Deepen Republican Party Divide
Zuckerberg Faces $8 Billion Privacy Lawsuit From Meta Shareholders
FIFA Pressured to Rethink World Cup Calendar Due to Climate Change
SpaceX Nears $400 Billion Valuation With New Share Sale
Microsoft, US Lab to Use AI for Faster Nuclear Plant Licensing
Trump Walks Back Talk of Firing Fed Chair Jerome Powell
Zelensky Reshuffles Cabinet to Win Support at Home and in Washington
"Can You Hit Moscow?" Trump Asked Zelensky To Make Putin "Feel The Pain"
Irish Tech Worker Detained 100 days by US Authorities for Overstaying Visa
Dimon Warns on Fed Independence as Trump Administration Eyes Powell’s Succession
Church of England Removes 1991 Sexuality Guidelines from Clergy Selection
Superman Franchise Achieves Success with Latest Release
Hungary's Viktor Orban Rejects Agreements on Illegal Migration
Jeff Bezos Considers Purchasing Condé Nast as a Wedding Gift
Ghislaine Maxwell Says She’s Ready to Testify Before Congress on Epstein’s Criminal Empire
Bal des Pompiers: A Celebration of Community and Firefighter Culture in France
FBI Chief Kash Patel Denies Resignation Speculations Amid Epstein List Controversy
Air India Pilot’s Mental Health Records Under Scrutiny
Google Secures Windsurf AI Coding Team in $2.4 Billion Licence Deal
Jamie Dimon Warns Europe Is Losing Global Competitiveness and Flags Market Complacency
South African Police Minister Suspended Amid Organised Crime Allegations
Nvidia CEO Claims Chinese Military Reluctance to Use US AI Technology
Hong Kong Advances Digital Asset Strategy to Address Economic Challenges
Australia Rules Out Pre‑commitment of Troops, Reinforces Defence Posture Amid US‑China Tensions
Martha Wells Says Humanity Still Far from True Artificial Intelligence
Nvidia Becomes World’s First Four‑Trillion‑Dollar Company Amid AI Boom
U.S. Resumes Deportations to Third Countries After Supreme Court Ruling
Excavation Begins at Site of Mass Grave for Children at Former Irish Institution
×