London Daily

Focus on the big picture.
Friday, Mar 14, 2025

British Court Denies Man’s Appeal to Search Landfill for Bitcoin Worth $765 Million

James Howells loses 11-year legal battle to recover a hard drive allegedly containing private keys to 8,000 Bitcoin.
A British court has rejected the appeal of James Howells, a Welsh man who sought permission to search a Newport landfill for a hard drive he claims contains private keys to 8,000 Bitcoin, currently valued at approximately $765 million.

Howells has been engaged in this legal battle since 2013, when the hard drive was mistakenly discarded.

The High Court judge ruled in favor of Newport City Council, citing environmental concerns and legal statutes, including the UK Pollution Control Act of 1974. The council argued that excavating the landfill could release harmful materials into the environment, posing risks to local residents.

The judge concluded there was no reasonable basis for the case to proceed to trial, emphasizing that Howells's request presented 'no realistic prospect of success.'

The legal dispute centers on a hard drive Howells claims to have inadvertently thrown away during a house cleanup in 2013. He asserts that the device contains a wallet file, wallet.dat, with the private key needed to access Bitcoin he mined in 2009. At the time, Bitcoin held minimal value, but its meteoric rise has transformed the cryptocurrency into a highly sought-after asset.

Howells filed his lawsuit in May 2024, seeking either permission to search the landfill or compensation equal to the value of the inaccessible Bitcoin.

The council, however, maintained that the discarded hard drive became its property under waste management laws once it was deposited in the landfill.

The court further cited the UK's statute of limitations, noting that Howells was aware of the facts of his claim as early as November 2013 but failed to initiate legal proceedings until over a decade later.

These delays, combined with the environmental risks posed by excavation, led to the court's decision to grant a summary judgment in favor of Newport City Council.

Significantly, the court did not address whether the hard drive indeed contains the Bitcoin, as the case primarily focused on issues of ownership and access rights.

Howells’s request to dig through the landfill has been consistently denied by Newport authorities, who maintain that the potential environmental hazards outweigh the speculative value of the search.

The case has drawn widespread attention, highlighting the challenges associated with lost cryptocurrency and the legal complexities of ownership once items enter the waste management system.

While Howells has described the ruling as another blow from what he terms the 'British system of injustice,' the court's decision underscores the stringent environmental and procedural standards that govern such disputes.

This decision marks the end of Howells's 11-year quest to retrieve his lost fortune, leaving questions about the fate of the hard drive—and the Bitcoin it may or may not contain—unresolved.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Meta Set to Introduce Community Notes Feature in March as Part of New Content Moderation Approach
Trump Family in Discussions for Investment in Binance
UK Prime Minister Suggests Significant Changes to the Governance of the National Health Service.
France Takes Strong Stance Against Potential US Tariffs on Alcoholic Drinks
Donatella Versace to Resign as Creative Director Following Almost 30 Years.
Trump's Ambassador Nominee Confirmed Canada’s Autonomy in the Face of Trade Strains
Netanyahu Rejects UN Conclusions on Gaza as 'Untrue'
Trump Speaks on the Possibility of a Ukraine Ceasefire Amid Continued Tensions
Trump Reaffirms Interest in Greenland Acquisition Amid Geopolitical Issues
French Prime Minister Bayrou Declares Position Against US Tariff Menaces
These are currently increasing in the UK.
Trump's Encounter with the Irish Prime Minister Takes an Unforeseen Twist Regarding Fashion and Economic Matters.
Isabel, a Russian native, wed Zahid Ali Khan, describing it as "love at first sight." She adores him for his character, not his $740 million fortune.
Chair Refers to Transgender Representative as 'Mr. McBride' During Congressional Meeting
The ICC's Revenge on Behalf of Drug Dealers, Against Philippine President Duterte, Who Fought Them and Saved 100 Million Filipinos from the Drugs-Death Industry—ignoring the fact that every victory comes at a cost
Canada Expresses Concerns Regarding U.S. Trade Policies Before G7 Meeting
FBI Alerts of Increasing Smishing Scams Aiming at Mobile Users
World Bank Officials Facing Examination for Travel-Related Carbon Emissions
EU and Canada Declare Countermeasures in Response to U.S. Steel and Aluminum Tariffs
Tiger Woods and Elin Nordegren: An In-Depth Exploration of Their Marital Struggles and Current Co-Parenting Efforts
Ex-Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte Detained in Manila Under ICC Warrant
Mark Carney Chosen as Head of Canada's Liberal Party, Poised to Assume Role of Prime Minister
Russia Kicks Out British Diplomats in Escalated Tensions
Significant Rescue Effort in Progress Following Collision Between Tanker and Cargo Ship in the North Sea
Pope Francis Exhibits Signs of Recovery, Yet Remains Hospitalized
Report of Radioactive Coolant Leak at Europe’s Largest Nuclear Reactor
Trump Administration Launches Self-Deportation App for Undocumented Immigrants
Syria Wraps Up Military Campaign Amid Extensive Violence and Large-Scale Executions
Trump Remarks on the Arrest of a Pro-Palestinian Student at Columbia University
Former Labour MP Mike Amesbury to Resign Following Assault Conviction
Chancellor Rachel Reeves Prepares for Spring Statement Amid Economic Challenges
Home Secretary Denies Public Inquiry into Sir David Amess's Murder
UK Energy Bills to Increase by 80 Pence to Support Discounts for Households Near Pylons
Russian Teacher Under Investigation After Explicit Content Incident in Classroom
Poland Plans Comprehensive Military Training for All Adult Males Amid Enhanced Defense Initiatives
Lithuania Withdraws from Cluster Munitions Convention Amid Security Concerns
Escalating Vandalism Targets Tesla Amid Political Controversies
Former Security Adviser Cautions That UK Troop Presence in Ukraine May Last for Years
Demonstrations Break Out as Individual Ascends Big Ben Carrying Palestinian Flag
Reform UK MP Rupert Lowe Suspended Amid Allegations of Violence and Bullying
Private spacecraft Athena has successfully landed close to the Moon's south pole.
Trump Administration Unveils Gold Card Visa Program Exempting Foreign Assets from U.S. Taxation
Trump Holds White House Summit for Cryptocurrency Leaders Amid Financial Scandals
Ukraine's Foreign Minister Highlights the Importance of the US in Attaining Peace
Trump Discovers Negotiating with Russia More Manageable than with Ukraine During Ongoing Conflict
Google Eliminates Women's History Month and Various Cultural Celebrations from Calendar App
Pope Francis Offers Thanks Despite Continuing Health Issues
King Charles III Reveals Curated Playlist on Apple Music in Anticipation of Commonwealth Day.
Disney's Biggest Cruise Ship Set to Debut in Singapore
Pamela Bach-Hasselhoff, the former 'Baywatch' star, tragically took her own life at the age of 62.
×